Soru

Zorluk: KolayArgument Development and Evidence Sequencing

In 1912, German meteorologist Alfred Wegener proposed the theory of continental drift, arguing that Earth’s continents were once joined in a single landmass called Pangaea before drifting apart. To support this radical claim, Wegener constructed a multi-layered argument, sequencing distinct categories of geological and biological evidence.

Wegener began his argument with a simple, visual observation: the puzzle-like fit of continental coastlines. He pointed out that the eastern coast of South America and the western coast of Africa appeared as if they could lock together. Recognizing that coastal erosion made this fit imperfect, he refined his observation by comparing the edges of the stable continental shelves rather than the shoreline boundaries, revealing an even more precise match.

To demonstrate that this fit was not coincidental, Wegener next introduced geological evidence. He identified identical rock sequences, mountain ranges, and coal deposits on opposite sides of the Atlantic Ocean. For instance, the Appalachian mountain system of North America lined up perfectly with the Caledonian mountains of Scotland and Scandinavia. Wegener argued that these structures could only have formed continuously if the landmasses were connected.

Wegener then bolstered his theory by citing paleontological data. He pointed to fossil remains of identical species found in locations separated by vast oceans. The Mesosaurus, a freshwater reptile incapable of swimming across saltwater, was found only in eastern South America and western Africa. Wegener argued that these distributions proved the existence of land bridges or, more likely, contiguous continents, as the species could not have crossed the modern Atlantic.

Finally, Wegener incorporated paleoclimatic data, showing that ancient glacial deposits and tropical coal beds lay in regions that currently have incompatible climates. By showing that equatorial regions once experienced glaciation while northern regions were tropical, he argued that the continents had shifted relative to the equator. Although Wegener’s theory was initially rejected because he could not identify the physical mechanism driving the movement, his careful sequencing of diverse evidence laid the groundwork for modern plate tectonics.

Based on the passage, arrange the pieces of evidence Alfred Wegener uses to support his theory of continental drift in the order they are introduced to develop his argument.

  1. 1Wegener notes the complementary shapes of the continental shelves of South America and Africa.
  2. 2Wegener compares matching mountain ranges and rock sequences on opposite sides of the ocean.
  3. 3Wegener identifies identical fossils of species like the Mesosaurus on separated landmasses.
  4. 4Wegener points out geological traces of ancient climates that do not align with current latitudes.

Cevap

The correct sequence starts with the observation of the matching continental shelves, followed by matching mountain ranges and rock sequences, then the distribution of identical fossils, and concludes with the analysis of ancient climates.
The passage builds Alfred Wegener's argument by first presenting the visual fit of continental shelves in the second paragraph, then matching geological formations in the third paragraph, followed by identical fossil distributions in the fourth paragraph, and finally paleoclimatic evidence in the fifth paragraph.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Locate the introduction of the first piece of evidence in the text.
The second paragraph describes Wegener beginning his argument with the puzzle-like fit of continental coastlines and shelves.
This establishes the starting point of the argument's evidence sequence.
2
Find the second category of evidence presented by the author.
The third paragraph introduces geological evidence, specifically identical rock sequences and matching mountain systems like the Appalachians and Caledonians.
This shows the next logical step in Wegener's argument to prove the fit was not coincidental.
3
Find the third category of evidence in the text.
The fourth paragraph describes the paleontological data, citing identical fossils of the Mesosaurus on opposite sides of the ocean.
This adds biological proof to the physical alignment of landmasses.
4
Identify the final category of evidence used to complete the argument.
The fifth paragraph details the paleoclimatic data, mentioning glacial deposits and tropical coal beds in unexpected locations.
This serves as the final supportive pillar of Wegener's theory of continental movement.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying the organizational progression and sequencing of evidence within a passage's argument.
Bu soruyu puanla