Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: KolayIdentifying Points of Disagreement

Two students discuss the source of the heat that powers the high-speed winds in Planet Y's atmosphere.

*Student 1*
Planet Y's winds are driven entirely by geothermal heat rising from the planet's hot interior. The planet is covered by a dense layer of dust that reflects 100% of incoming sunlight back into space, meaning solar energy does not heat the atmosphere at all.

*Student 2*
Planet Y's winds are powered entirely by solar radiation. Although the dust layer reflects most sunlight, the top of the dust layer absorbs enough solar energy to create large temperature differences in the upper atmosphere, driving the winds. Geothermal heat from the core is too weak to reach the atmosphere.

Match each atmospheric factor on the left with the correct description of the students' disagreement regarding that factor on the right.

  • Geothermal heatStudent 1 claims it is the sole driver of the winds, whereas Student 2 claims it is too weak to reach the atmosphere.
  • Solar radiationStudent 2 claims it is the sole driver of the winds, whereas Student 1 claims it is completely reflected and plays no role.
  • Dust layer absorptionStudent 1 claims it reflects 100% of light and prevents solar heating, whereas Student 2 claims it absorbs enough energy to drive wind.

Cevap

Geothermal heat matches with the description that Student 1 claims it drives the winds while Student 2 claims it is too weak. Solar radiation matches with the description that Student 2 claims it drives the winds while Student 1 claims it is reflected. Dust layer absorption matches with the description that Student 1 claims it prevents solar heating while Student 2 claims it absorbs energy.
The correct matches accurately pair the physical factors with the conflicting assertions of the two students. Specifically, geothermal heat is the driver according to Student 1 but too weak according to Student 2; solar radiation is the driver according to Student 2 but completely reflected according to Student 1; and the dust layer completely reflects solar energy according to Student 1 but absorbs it according to Student 2.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze Student 1's view on each factor.
Student 1 believes geothermal heat drives winds, solar radiation plays no role, and the dust layer reflects 100% of sunlight.
To establish a baseline for Student 1's claims.
2
Analyze Student 2's view on each factor.
Student 2 believes solar radiation drives winds, geothermal heat is too weak to reach the atmosphere, and the dust layer absorbs solar energy in its upper layer.
To establish a baseline for Student 2's claims.
3
Compare their views for each factor to identify points of disagreement.
For geothermal heat, Student 1 says it drives winds while Student 2 says it is too weak. For solar radiation, Student 2 says it drives winds while Student 1 says it is reflected. For the dust layer, Student 1 says it reflects everything, while Student 2 says it absorbs solar energy.
To correctly pair the physical factors with the descriptions of the students' disagreements.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying points of disagreement between conflicting scientific viewpoints
Tahmini Süre:1m 0s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Identifying Points of Disagreement

Bu konudan daha fazla soru