Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: ZorAligning Data and Predictions with Viewpoints

Two scientists debate the cause of the Younger Dryas (YD), a period of abrupt cooling that occurred approximately 12,900 years ago.

Scientist 1
The YD was triggered by a massive influx of freshwater into the North Atlantic Ocean from the melting Laurentide Ice Sheet. This freshwater reduced the salinity and density of surface waters, shutting down the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), which transports heat from the tropics to the high latitudes. According to this view, marine sediment cores should show a sudden drop in salinity (indicated by oxygen isotope ratios in planktonic shells) exactly at the onset of the YD. Furthermore, the cooling should be localized primarily in the Northern Hemisphere, while the Southern Hemisphere warmed or remained stable.

Scientist 2
The YD was triggered by an impact event from a fragmented comet or asteroid. The impact caused widespread wildfires, blocked sunlight with soot and dust, and disrupted global climate. According to this view, the cooling was global and synchronous. Sediment layers dating exactly to the onset of the YD should contain high concentrations of impact proxies (such as nanodiamonds, microspherules, and iridium) and soot from biomass burning globally, regardless of latitude, while North Atlantic ocean circulation patterns would show no sudden, primary changes.

Match each new scientific finding on the left with the viewpoint it supports.

  • Sediment cores from the Southern Hemisphere show warming at 12,900 years ago, and North Atlantic plankton fossils indicate a sudden, massive drop in sea surface salinity.Supports Scientist 1 only
  • Ice cores from Greenland and Antarctica show that cooling began synchronously in both hemispheres 12,900 years ago, accompanied by global peaks in iridium and nanodiamond concentrations.Supports Scientist 2 only
  • Sediment layers dating to 12,900 years ago contain both a distinct layer of nanodiamonds and a sudden, sharp decrease in sea surface salinity in the North Atlantic.Supports both Scientist 1 and Scientist 2
  • High-resolution sediment cores reveal that global temperatures, North Atlantic salinity, and atmospheric soot concentrations remained completely stable 12,900 years ago.Contradicts both Scientist 1 and Scientist 2

Cevap

The finding of localized cooling and salinity drop supports Scientist 1 only; synchronous cooling and impact proxies support Scientist 2 only; both markers appearing supports both scientists; and stable climate markers contradict both scientists.
The correct matches align the empirical findings with the unique predictions made by each scientist. Localized cooling and salinity changes support Scientist 1, impact proxies and global cooling support Scientist 2, the presence of both supports both, and the absence of any changes contradicts both.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the key predictions of Scientist 1.
Scientist 1 predicts localized Northern Hemisphere cooling (Southern Hemisphere warming/stability) and a sudden drop in North Atlantic salinity at 12,900 years ago.
To align data, we must first establish the expected evidence for the meltwater hypothesis.
2
Identify the key predictions of Scientist 2.
Scientist 2 predicts global, synchronous cooling, high soot, and global impact proxies (nanodiamonds, iridium) at 12,900 years ago.
To align data, we must establish the expected evidence for the impact hypothesis.
3
Match each hypothetical finding to the corresponding prediction.
Finding 1 matches Scientist 1's localized temperature and salinity predictions. Finding 2 matches Scientist 2's global cooling and impact proxy predictions. Finding 3 combines elements of both. Finding 4 shows no change, contradicting both.
Logical mapping confirms which hypothesis is supported or contradicted by the new empirical evidence.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating how new empirical findings support, contradict, or neutralise competing scientific hypotheses based on their specific predictions.
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Aligning Data and Predictions with Viewpoints

Bu konudan daha fazla soru