Read the following excerpt from the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Giles v. Harris (1903), written by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.:
"The plaintiff faces a dilemma... If the conspiracy and the intent exist, a bill on these lines [to register Black voters] would be an empty form. Remedy for a conspiracy that has writ itself into the law of the State, and which the State is endeavoring to carry out, it would seem, must be given by the State itself, or by Congress."
Based on the excerpt, which of the following statements best analyzes the federal government's role in the consolidation of legal segregation and disenfranchisement during the early Jim Crow era?
- It established a precedent where the federal judiciary declined to intervene against state-sponsored voter suppression, leaving the protection of political rights to hostile state governments or Congress.Cevap
- BIt targeted the eradication of customary, de facto segregation in Northern employment rather than addressing state-enforced, de jure disenfranchisement laws in the South.
- CIt declared that Southern disenfranchisement schemes were legal because they utilized the Thirteenth Amendment loophole that permits involuntary servitude as criminal punishment.
- DIt determined that disenfranchisement was justified because sharecropping arrangements functioned as equitable labor contracts that successfully integrated former slaves into the economy.
Cevap
The ruling established a precedent where the federal judiciary declined to intervene against state-sponsored voter suppression, leaving the protection of political rights to hostile state governments or Congress.
The correct answer is correct because Giles v. Harris (1903) was a landmark Supreme Court decision in which the Court refused to order Alabama officials to register Black voters, claiming that the judiciary lacked the power to enforce political rights in a state that was determined to deny them. This decision effectively gave federal approval to Southern disenfranchisement measures and shifted the burden of protecting voting rights onto Congress or the states themselves, neither of which took action.
Adım Adım Çözüm
Anahtar Kavram
Disenfranchisement, legal segregation, and the federal judiciary's role in failing to protect Black political rights under Jim Crow.