Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaNarrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

(1) I must admit, Mr. Sterling is a man of singularly narrow horizons, a fact that became
(2) painfully obvious during our first discussion regarding his son's education. He sat
(3) in his leather-bound chair, clutching a ledger as though it were holy scripture, and
(4) spoke only of arithmetic and ledger-entries, entirely dismissing the classical curriculum
(5) I proposed. "Latin will not buy flour," he remarked with that crude, practical air that
(6) characterizes the mercantile class of our town. I listened with a polite, if strained,
(7) smile, pitying a mind so utterly blind to the finer textures of human thought. He
(8) believes himself a benefactor, ensuring his son's future, yet he is merely building a
(9) gilded cage of numbers. Later, when the boy struggled to translate a simple passage of
(10) Virgil, Mr. Sterling entered the study and patted the child's shoulder, murmuring that
(11) a ledger requires no translation. It is clear to any detached observer that the man
(12) fears his son might outshine him, and thus actively seeks to suppress the boy's natural
(13) intellectual curiosity under the guise of practical guidance.

The narrator's explanation of Mr. Sterling's behavior in lines 11–13 ('It is clear... guidance') reveals a bias that is primarily rooted in which of the following?

  1. The narrator's own intellectual arrogance and class-based condescension, which prevent him from recognizing Mr. Sterling's genuine parental concernCevap
  2. B
    An accurate, objective recognition of Mr. Sterling's underlying desire to prevent his son from achieving academic success
  3. C
    A shared philosophical alignment with the author's disdain for the pragmatic values of the rising mercantile class
  4. D
    The narrator's deep resentment over Mr. Sterling's constant interruptions and his refusal to pay the agreed-upon tutoring wages
  5. E
    An omniscient, third-person perspective that remains detached from the emotional dynamics of the household

Cevap

The narrator's own intellectual arrogance and class-based condescension, which prevent him from recognizing Mr. Sterling's genuine parental concern
The correct option accurately points out that the narrator's interpretation is colored by his intellectual vanity and class bias. As a tutor of the classics, he looks down on Mr. Sterling's mercantile pragmatism, assuming that the father's encouragement of practical skills is a malicious attempt to keep the son from outshining him.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the narrator's point of view and tone.
The narrative is written in the first person, and the narrator displays a condescending tone toward Mr. Sterling's mercantile background and emphasis on practical ledgers over Latin.
Identifying the narrator's perspective and tone is crucial to recognizing their subjectivity.
2
Evaluate the narrator's claims about Mr. Sterling's motives in lines 11–13.
The narrator asserts that Mr. Sterling fears his son might outshine him and seeks to suppress the boy's natural intellectual curiosity. However, the text only shows Mr. Sterling offering practical advice and showing warmth.
Comparing the narrator's assertions with the actual depicted actions of the character reveals the bias in the narrator's interpretation.
3
Select the option that correctly identifies the source of the narrator's bias.
The narrator's own intellectual vanity and prejudice against the mercantile class lead him to construct a hostile motive for Mr. Sterling's pragmatism.
The correct option must explain the psychological or social root of the narrator's unreliable interpretation.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying narrator bias and its effect on character portrayal
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Narrator Reliability, Perspective, and Bias

Bu konudan daha fazla soru