Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCharacter Change and Stasis

Directions: The passage below is an excerpt from a short story. Read the passage carefully and then choose the best answer to the question.

Gregory watched the tide-charts with the same silent devotion he had paid them for forty years, though the harbor itself had long since ceased to harbor anything but the sleek, fiberglass hulls of yachts he did not own. Every morning, he walked the length of the wooden pier, counting the rotting pine planks that groaned beneath his boots, a familiar scale of decay. The new marina rose to the east, all steel pilings and tinted glass, reflecting a sterile blue sky that seemed entirely disconnected from the grey salt spray of his youth. The town council had offered to buy his slip, calling it an "eyesore of historical interest," but Gregory had simply turned his back. He knew the precise depth at which the sandbar shifted under the autumn gales; he knew how the northeaster rattled the loose shingles on the fish house. To leave would mean admitting that the water could exist without him, or worse, that he could exist without the water. So he stood at the pier's end, a weathered piling himself, rooted in the muck while the tides of progress washed around his ankles.

In the final sentence of the passage, the narrator's comparison of Gregory to a "weathered piling" primarily serves to emphasize which of the following?

  1. A
    The author's critique of the environmental damage caused by the new marina's construction
  2. B
    A literal description of Gregory's physical decline and deteriorating health
  3. His psychological stasis and refusal to adapt to the harbor’s modernizationCevap
  4. D
    His plan to eventually accept the town council's financial offer for his slip
  5. E
    His realization that his relationship with the harbor has become superficial

Cevap

His psychological stasis and refusal to adapt to the harbor’s modernization
The comparison of Gregory to a 'weathered piling' that is 'rooted in the muck' highlights his immobility and psychological stasis. While the surrounding harbor changes around him ('the tides of progress'), Gregory remains fixed in his ways and connected to the past, refusing to adapt or move.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the passage to identify the narrator's attitude towards Gregory's relationship with the harbor.
The passage details Gregory's resistance to the new marina and the council's offer, establishing his physical and psychological immobility.
Understanding the character's internal state is necessary to interpret the final metaphorical comparison.
2
Interpret the metaphor 'weathered piling' in the context of the final sentence.
A piling is a heavy post driven into the seabed to support a structure; describing Gregory as 'weathered' and 'rooted in the muck' highlights his permanence and resistance to the 'tides of progress.'
The metaphor explicitly contrasts Gregory's static nature with the dynamic, changing community.
3
Evaluate the options to select the one that aligns with Gregory's resistance to change.
The option stating 'His psychological stasis and refusal to adapt to the harbor’s modernization' is the only one supported by the text's emphasis on his immobility.
This option correctly identifies character stasis as the main function of the literary device in the context of the passage.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying and analyzing character stasis and resistance to change in short fiction
Bu soruyu puanla