Soru

Zorluk: OrtaIdentifying Main Ideas and Supporting Details

The following excerpt is taken from an analytical essay on ecological engineering and climate resilience:

"High in the Peruvian Andes, hydrologists and local communities are reviving an ingenious pre-Columbian water harvesting system known as amunas. These ancestral stone canals, built over a millennium ago by the Wari civilization, capture torrential runoff during the brief highland wet season and channel it into permeable mountain slopes. The water slowly filters through subsurface aquifers, taking months to emerge from downhill natural springs precisely during the hyper-arid dry season. As tropical glaciers in the Cordillera Central experience accelerated retreat due to global warming, Lima’s downstream reservoirs face unprecedented seasonal deficits. Rather than relying solely on multi-billion-dollar concrete mega-dams that disrupt delicate high-altitude bogs, civil engineers are now partnering with indigenous communal water boards to restore hundreds of kilometers of silted amunas. Initial tracer studies confirm that this decentralized, nature-based infrastructure recharges millions of cubic meters of groundwater at a fraction of conventional capital costs. The integration of ancient hydrological wisdom with contemporary sensor monitoring represents not a nostalgic retreat into the past, but an economically viable blueprint for regional climate adaptation."

Which of the following statements best identifies the central idea of the passage?

  1. A
    Tracer studies verify that seasonal runoff filtering through mountain aquifers takes months to discharge into natural springs.
  2. Restoring ancestral Andean water channels provides a cost-effective, sustainable framework for mitigating water shortages caused by glacial retreat.Cevap
  3. C
    Modern civil engineers have determined that concrete mega-dam construction should be entirely abandoned across South America.
  4. D
    The revival of pre-Columbian canals is primarily a cultural heritage tribute rather than a scientifically viable hydrological solution.

Cevap

Restoring ancestral Andean water channels provides a cost-effective, sustainable framework for mitigating water shortages caused by glacial retreat.
The correct statement captures the comprehensive argument developed throughout the essay: the integration of restored pre-Columbian hydrological infrastructure with modern engineering offers a practical, low-cost solution to the severe water security challenges posed by Andean glacial retreat.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the structural organization and thematic development of the passage.
The text introduces the mechanism of ancestral amunas, defines the urgent challenge of glacial retreat affecting urban reservoirs, and concludes that combining this indigenous infrastructure with modern monitoring provides an economically viable climate adaptation strategy.
Identifying the problem-solution structure allows the reader to separate the primary claim from contextual background.
2
Distinguish the primary thesis from specific supporting data and evidence.
The physical filtration timeline and tracer study metrics serve as supporting evidence demonstrating how the system functions and confirming its feasibility, while the central argument addresses the broader viability of nature-based ancestral solutions for modern water security.
A main idea must encompass the entire scope of the text rather than isolating an individual technical detail.
3
Evaluate the answer choices against the author's synthesized conclusion.
The statement highlighting the restoration of ancestral channels as an economically viable, sustainable response to climate-induced water deficits accurately captures the complete thesis without introducing unwarranted claims or narrow details.
The correct synthesis directly aligns with the concluding assertion of the essay.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Main Ideas and Supporting Details in Journalistic Texts
Bu soruyu puanla