An analysis of a technology firm's policy statement reveals a logical flaw based on equivocation:
"Our committee mandates that all software deployments must ensure user security. Comprehensive data encryption guarantees technical security against external cyberattacks. Therefore, deploying robust data encryption fully satisfies a technology firm's ethical security responsibilities toward its customer base."
Match each key term from the argument on the left to the specific shift in meaning it undergoes between the premise context and the conclusion context on the right.
- SecurityShifts from narrow technical protection of digital information to broad ethical safeguarding of user interests.
- Satisfies responsibilitiesShifts from complying with specific technical data parameters to fulfilling overall moral and social duties.
- External cyberattacksShifts from unauthorized network intrusions by third parties to any general breach of user trust or safety.
Cevap
The correct matches are: 'Security' matches with the shift from technical protection to broad ethical safeguarding; 'Satisfies responsibilities' matches with the shift from technical compliance to fulfilling overall moral duties; and 'External cyberattacks' matches with the shift from technical network intrusions to general breaches of user trust.
The argument commits an equivocation flaw by introducing terms under narrow, technical definitions in the premises and quietly broadening their definitions in the conclusion. 'Security' shifts from technical data protection to comprehensive ethical duty; 'Satisfies responsibilities' shifts from meeting specific software parameters to fulfilling complete moral duties; and 'External cyberattacks' shifts from specific cyber intrusions to any violation of consumer trust.
Adım Adım Çözüm
Anahtar Kavram
Equivocation and Shift in Term Meaning