Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: KolayConfusing Necessary and Sufficient Conditions

To secure a promotion to senior analyst at Meridian Financial, an employee is required to complete the advanced risk modeling certification. David, a junior analyst, has successfully passed the final examination for this advanced certification this week. Therefore, the company's executive management committee will undoubtedly promote David to senior analyst during the upcoming annual performance review cycle.

Which of the following best describes the flaw in the argument's reasoning?

  1. It treats a condition that is required for promotion as though it were sufficient to guarantee that promotion.Cevap
  2. B
    It mistakes a statistical correlation between certification and promotion for a direct causal relationship.
  3. C
    It assumes without evidence that David's exam performance reflects his overall day-to-day competence.
  4. D
    It ignores the possibility that preparing for the certification exam negatively impacted David's routine tasks.
  5. E
    It assumes that no junior analyst other than David has completed the advanced risk modeling certification.

Cevap

The argument's flaw is that it treats a condition necessary for promotion as sufficient to guarantee that promotion.
The argument states that completing the certification is required for a promotion (a necessary condition). However, the author concludes that because David met this requirement, he is guaranteed to be promoted. Meeting a necessary condition does not guarantee the outcome, as other unstated requirements may exist.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the premises and conclusion in the passage.
Premise: Completing the certification is required ('must/is required to') for promotion. Premise: David completed the certification. Conclusion: David will certainly be promoted.
Deconstructing the argument reveals the formal logical structure connecting the condition to the outcome.
2
Analyze the logical relationship between the condition and the outcome.
The phrase 'required to complete' indicates that certification is a necessary condition, not a sufficient one. Other factors (such as job performance or position availability) might also be required.
Differentiating between necessary (required) and sufficient (guaranteed) conditions exposes the leap in logic.
3
Select the option that accurately describes this conditional logic error.
The option stating that a required condition is mistaken as a guarantee accurately captures this flaw.
Mistaking a requirement for a guarantee is the classic definition of confusing necessary and sufficient conditions.

Anahtar Kavram

Confusing Necessary and Sufficient Conditions
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Confusing Necessary and Sufficient Conditions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru