Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: KolayStrengthening or Weakening Author Assertions

In recent decades, economic historians have debated the primary driver behind the rapid expansion of manufacturing in early nineteenth-century New England. Traditional accounts emphasize the role of imported British technology, arguing that American industrialists merely replicated established European production methods. However, historian Sarah Mercer contends that local institutional support—specifically, municipal tax exemptions—was far more decisive. Mercer points out that while British designs were widely available across all American regions, manufacturing clusters emerged almost exclusively in towns that offered explicit tax abatements to textile mill operators.

To support her assertion, Mercer highlights that between 1810 and 1830, textile output grew three times faster in New England towns with local tax incentives than in neighboring towns that possessed identical access to British machinery but lacked such tax relief. From this disparity, Mercer concludes that financial incentives provided by municipal governments were the critical factor encouraging entrepreneurs to risk capital on new industrial ventures.

Which of the following, if true, would most strengthen Mercer's assertion regarding the role of municipal tax exemptions?

  1. Textile mill founders surveyed during the 1820s explicitly cited municipal tax exemptions as their primary reason for choosing specific New England towns over locations with cheaper labor.Cevap
  2. B
    Towns offering tax exemptions frequently experienced severe municipal budget deficits that prevented them from investing in local road and canal infrastructure.
  3. C
    In the late twentieth century, state tax breaks became the single most effective policy instrument for attracting technology firms to rural areas.
  4. D
    British machine designers frequently sought patent protections in the United States to safeguard their mechanical innovations from unauthorized copying.
  5. E
    Several New England towns without manufacturing incentives experienced steady population growth from agricultural expansion during the same period.

Cevap

The correct option is the one stating that mill founders explicitly cited tax exemptions as their primary reason for site selection, as it directly confirms the causal link asserted by the author.
The correct choice directly validates Mercer's conclusion by providing primary historical evidence that mill operators actively chose locations based on municipal tax exemptions. This directly bridges the gap between correlation (faster growth in tax-exempt towns) and causation (tax exemptions caused the growth).

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the author's core assertion
Mercer asserts that municipal tax exemptions were the decisive factor driving the expansion of textile manufacturing in early nineteenth-century New England.
Understanding the precise claim is required before evaluating which statement strengthens it.
2
Identify what evidence would strengthen this causal relationship
Evidence demonstrating that entrepreneurs actually relied on tax exemptions when making investment decisions directly reinforces Mercer's conclusion.
A premise directly connecting the incentive to the decision-makers' actions validates the causal mechanism.
3
Evaluate the answer choices against the strengthening requirement
Direct survey evidence from mill founders confirming that tax exemptions dictated their location choices provides direct support for the assertion.
This removes potential alternative explanations and confirms the author's underlying assumption.

Anahtar Kavram

Strengthening Author Assertions
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Strengthening or Weakening Author Assertions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru