Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorErrors of Composition and Division

Chief Technology Officer: Every individual software module created for our new automated trading platform executes its trade directives in under two microseconds and operates with zero memory leaks. Furthermore, every hardware unit housing these modules maintains a 99.99 percent operational uptime. Therefore, the complete trading platform, when fully integrated from these software modules and hardware units, will execute all trade directives in under two microseconds while maintaining complete system stability. Which of the following identifies the reasoning flaw in the Chief Technology Officer's argument?

  1. It assumes that a characteristic belonging to each individual component of a system is necessarily a property of the whole system constructed from those components.Cevap
  2. B
    It confuses a subsidiary claim regarding individual software execution speed with the argument's final main conclusion.
  3. C
    It presumes that because automated trading platforms share surface similarities with other high-frequency financial tools, their hardware units follow identical operating constraints.
  4. D
    It mistakes a condition that is necessary for complete platform stability for a condition that is sufficient to guarantee zero execution latency.
  5. E
    It draws a general conclusion about overall system reliability based on an unrepresentative sample of software modules and hardware units.

Cevap

The argument commits the fallacy of composition by improperly concluding that a whole system must possess a property simply because every individual component of that system possesses it.
The correct choice accurately identifies the fallacy of composition. The Chief Technology Officer improperly infers that because each individual software module and hardware unit executes rapidly and reliably in isolation, the integrated platform as a whole will maintain identical performance. In complex systems, interactions between components, network latency, and integration bottlenecks often degrade aggregate performance beyond the metrics of individual parts.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the argument's premises and scope.
Premise 1 states that every individual software module executes in under 2 microseconds with zero memory leaks. Premise 2 states that every hardware unit has 99.99 percent uptime.
Isolating the premises clarifies the specific claims made regarding individual system parts.
2
Identify the conclusion and the inferential step.
The conclusion asserts that the entire integrated trading platform will execute directives in under 2 microseconds with complete stability.
The argument transitions directly from attributes of individual modules/units to the attribute of the fully integrated whole.
3
Evaluate the flaw in reasoning.
System integration introduces communication overhead, sequential execution dependencies, and routing latency. Therefore, parts operating in under 2 microseconds does not guarantee the combined whole operates at that aggregate speed.
Inferring that a whole possesses the properties of its separate parts is an Error of Composition.

Anahtar Kavram

Errors of Composition and Division
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Errors of Composition and Division

Bu konudan daha fazla soru