Soru

Zorluk: ZorStrengthening Arguments

Archaeologists analyzing high-resolution synthetic aperture radar imagery of the Eastern Desert observed subsurface linear anomalies near ancient copper mines. Carbon dating of organic residue in nearby soil strata dates to the 12th century BCE. The researchers concluded that these linear anomalies represent buried irrigation canals constructed specifically to support the agricultural needs of the mining settlements.

Which of the following, if true, provides the strongest support for the researchers' conclusion?

  1. Soil samples extracted directly from inside the linear structures contain preserved pollen from cultivated grain crops that cannot survive in desert environments without artificial watering.Cevap
  2. B
    Geological surveys show that subterranean fault lines in the Eastern Desert naturally form linear patterns that trap organic sediment over centuries.
  3. C
    Synthetic aperture radar technology has been proven effective at detecting ancient subterranean trade routes in several other desert regions.
  4. D
    Copper smelting at the 12th-century BCE mining sites required substantial quantities of timber brought in from non-desert regions.
  5. E
    Metal production at the Eastern Desert mining settlements declined sharply towards the end of the 12th century BCE as local ore deposits became exhausted.

Cevap

The discovery of fossilized pollen from cultivated grain crops requiring artificial watering inside the linear structures provides direct empirical evidence that the anomalies were indeed irrigation canals built to support local agriculture.
The correct answer provides direct physical evidence connecting the subsurface linear structures to agricultural irrigation. Finding preserved pollen from crops that require artificial watering inside the features demonstrates that they functioned as water channels designed for crop cultivation, directly reinforcing the researchers' conclusion.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Deconstruct the argument into premise and conclusion
Premise: Radar imagery shows subsurface linear anomalies near 12th-century BCE copper mines, with nearby organic soil strata dating to that period. Conclusion: The anomalies are buried irrigation canals built to supply agricultural needs for the mining settlements.
Strengthening questions require identifying the logical gap between the evidence (linear shapes near mines) and the conclusion (irrigation canals for farming).
2
Identify the key assumption underlying the conclusion
The argument assumes that the linear anomalies are artificial structures intended for carrying water to crops rather than natural geological formations or non-agricultural conduits.
Providing evidence that directly links the interior of the structures to crop cultivation requiring diverted water validates this core assumption.
3
Evaluate the answer options against the strengthening objective
The option establishing the presence of crop pollen requiring artificial watering inside the structures explicitly confirms their agricultural and hydrological function.
Direct evidence of agricultural water usage inside the features supplies the missing evidentiary link.

Anahtar Kavram

Strengthening Arguments by Providing Direct Evidence for Unstated Assumptions
Bu soruyu puanla