Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaEvaluating Passage Arguments and Claims

Read the passage below:

For decades, economic historians attributed the rapid industrial growth of nineteenth-century regional hubs primarily to proximity to natural waterways. However, recent quantitative analyses suggest that localized private credit markets played a more decisive role in sustaining long-term capital investment. Critics of this revised thesis contend that private credit availability was merely a downstream effect of waterway access, arguing that maritime commerce generated the surplus capital required to establish banking institutions. Nevertheless, this objection overlooks evidence that several landlocked commercial centers developed robust, independent credit syndicates prior to the construction of major canal or river connections. Thus, the claim that waterway proximity was the primary catalyst for industrialization conflates trade volume with capital formation.

Evaluate the following statement: The author's counterargument against the critics relies on the assumption that the surplus capital in landlocked commercial centers did not originate from maritime commerce conducted elsewhere.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

The statement is True. The author's argument against the critics requires assuming that the credit in landlocked hubs did not ultimately derive from maritime commerce elsewhere.
The statement correctly identifies a necessary assumption of the author's counterargument. The critics argue that waterway trade was the ultimate origin of banking capital. The author cites landlocked hubs to prove credit existed independently of waterway access. If those landlocked hubs drew their capital from maritime trade conducted elsewhere, the critics' premise would hold true despite the lack of local direct waterways. Thus, the author must assume no such origin exists.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the critics' claim and the author's counterargument.
Critics claim that private credit is a downstream result of waterway trade because maritime commerce generated the surplus capital for banks. The author counters by citing landlocked centers that built credit syndicates prior to obtaining waterway connections.
Understanding the precise logical structure of the dispute is necessary to identify unstated assumptions.
2
Evaluate what assumption is necessary for the author's counter-evidence to successfully refute the critics.
If the landlocked centers' capital actually came from maritime trade in nearby hubs (e.g., via land trade or investors from river cities), then maritime trade was still the original source of the capital, supporting the critics.
An assumption is a premise that must be true for the argument's conclusion to logically hold.
3
Determine the validity of the statement.
Because the author's counterargument fails if the capital originated from maritime trade elsewhere, the author must assume that it did not originate from maritime commerce.
Confirming the necessity of this unstated assumption establishes that the statement is True.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating Unstated Assumptions in Passage Counterarguments
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Evaluating Passage Arguments and Claims

Bu konudan daha fazla soru