Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: ZorIdentifying Underlying Assumptions

A municipal water authority plans to filter industrial heavy-metal runoff by deploying permeable bio-char barriers produced from Melaleuca wood, an invasive tree species currently being cleared from local wetlands. Environmental engineers argue that this initiative will simultaneously reduce heavy-metal contamination in the municipal water supply and lower overall wetland restoration costs. They base this claim on data showing that Melaleuca bio-char binds heavy metals with high efficiency in laboratory settings, and that harvesting the wood for bio-char production will offset the expenses of clearing the invasive trees.

Which of the following statements represent necessary assumptions upon which the engineers' argument depends? Select all that apply.

  1. The chemical process used to convert harvested Melaleuca wood into bio-char does not produce toxic leachates that contaminate the water supply during filtration.Cevap
  2. B
    Deploying Melaleuca bio-char barriers is the most cost-effective method available for treating industrial heavy-metal runoff in urban municipal regions.
  3. The operational costs associated with processing and transporting harvested Melaleuca wood to filtration sites will not exceed the financial savings realized from clearing the trees.Cevap
  4. D
    Industrial heavy-metal runoff is the primary contributor to ecological degradation within the wetlands targeted for Melaleuca clearing.
  5. E
    Living Melaleuca trees absorb higher baseline concentrations of heavy metals from wetland soil than native plant species do.

Cevap

The argument depends on the assumptions that the bio-char conversion process does not produce toxic leachates that contaminate the water supply, and that processing and transportation costs for the harvested wood will not exceed the savings achieved from clearing the trees.
The conclusion asserts two distinct outcomes: reducing water contamination and lowering overall restoration costs. For contamination to be reduced, the bio-char production process must not introduce new pollutants into the water during filtration. For restoration costs to decrease, the logistical costs of processing and transporting the harvested wood must not surpass the cost savings obtained from clearing the invasive trees. Negating either of these statements directly invalidates one of the conclusion's core claims.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Deconstruct the argument structure into premises and conclusion
Premises: Melaleuca bio-char binds heavy metals efficiently in labs; using harvested wood offsets clearing expenses. Conclusion: The initiative will reduce heavy-metal contamination in the municipal supply and lower overall wetland restoration costs.
Identifying the explicit claims is necessary to locate unstated logical gaps between the evidence and the dual conclusion.
2
Apply the Negation Test to the statement regarding bio-char conversion leachates
Negated statement: The conversion process does produce toxic leachates that enter the water supply during filtration. If true, deploying the barriers fails to reduce water contamination, breaking the first half of the conclusion.
A statement whose negation invalidates a central conclusion is a required underlying assumption.
3
Apply the Negation Test to the statement regarding processing and transportation costs
Negated statement: Processing and transportation costs will exceed the financial savings realized from tree clearing. If true, net restoration expenses will rise, breaking the second half of the conclusion.
If processing costs outweigh harvesting offsets, overall restoration costs cannot decrease.
4
Evaluate and eliminate non-essential distractors
Statements concerning alternative method superiority, wetland degradation causes, and living tree absorption rates are unessential to the specific logical bridge of this argument.
Assumptions must be strictly necessary for the argument's validity, not merely helpful or topical facts.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Underlying Assumptions (Negation Test)
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Identifying Underlying Assumptions

Bu konudan daha fazla soru