A commercial property owner suffers a theft loss. The policy strictly requires the insured to submit a police report to the insurer within 48 hours of discovering the theft. The insured submits the report five days later. The insurer's claims department acknowledges receipt and sends a formal letter stating they will overlook the delay and proceed with the claim adjustment. After three months of the insured spending time and money obtaining appraisals at the insurer's request, the insurer abruptly attempts to deny the claim based solely on the late submission of the police report. Under insurance contract law, what legal reasoning prevents the insurer from legally denying this claim?
- AThe insurer's letter created an estoppel, which is defined as the intentional and voluntary relinquishment of a known legal right.
- BThe reporting deadline was a representation rather than a strict warranty, so the breach of this condition cannot be used to void the coverage.
- The insurer's letter constituted a waiver of the deadline, and estoppel now prevents them from reasserting that right after the insured relied on their decision.Cevap
- DThe claims department exercised apparent authority to permanently alter the written conditions of the issued policy.
Cevap
The insurer's letter constituted a waiver of the deadline, and estoppel now prevents them from reasserting that right after the insured relied on their decision.
The correct answer accurately applies both legal concepts: the insurer committed an express waiver by formally stating they would not enforce the deadline, and estoppel is the legal result that stops them from changing their mind after the insured acted upon that waiver to their own financial detriment.
Adım Adım Çözüm
Anahtar Kavram
Waiver and Estoppel in Claims Handling