Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorCommon Law and Precedents

The United Kingdom's legal system relies significantly on Common Law, often described as 'judge-made law'. When a judge establishes a new legal principle to resolve a case where no existing legislation applies, what is the most accurate description of how this principle functions as a source of law?

  1. It becomes a binding precedent that must be followed by lower courts in similar future cases, remaining in force until it is changed by a higher court's ruling or by a new Act of Parliament.Cevap
  2. B
    It serves as a temporary guideline that must be formally ratified as an Act of Parliament within one year to remain a valid source of law for future cases.
  3. C
    It is classified as a constitutional convention, which provides a traditional rule for political behaviour but lacks the legal authority to be enforced in a court of law.
  4. D
    Because the UK constitution is uncodified, the judge's decision immediately gains higher legal authority than any existing Statute Law passed by Parliament.

Cevap

The principle established by a judge becomes a binding precedent that lower courts must follow, and it remains law unless overturned by a higher court or a new Act of Parliament.
The correct answer reflects the principle of judicial precedent. In the UK, when a higher court makes a decision, it sets a 'binding' rule for lower courts to follow. This judge-made law remains in effect as part of the legal system unless a more senior court reaches a different conclusion in a future case or Parliament passes a Statute (Act of Parliament) that specifically changes that area of law.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the nature of Common Law.
Common Law is law developed by judges through court decisions rather than through Acts of Parliament.
This is the fundamental definition of the source of law being tested.
2
Analyze the authority of judicial decisions.
Decisions made by higher courts create 'precedents' that are binding on lower courts in similar situations.
This ensures consistency and predictability in the legal system (stare decisis).
3
Determine the relationship between Common Law and Statute Law.
While Common Law is binding, Parliament remains sovereign and can change any Common Law by passing a new Statute.
This maintains the constitutional hierarchy where elected legislators have the final say on the law.

Anahtar Kavram

Judicial Precedent and the Hierarchy of Laws
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Common Law and Precedents

Bu konudan daha fazla soru