Soru

Zorluk: OrtaInferences from the Text

In the late fourth millennium BCE in Uruk, Mesopotamian administrators transitioned from using clay tokens encased in sealed spherical envelopes (bullae) to pressing token impressions onto flat clay tablets, and ultimately to incising pictographic proto-cuneiform signs with a reed stylus. Early archaeological theories posited that this evolution represented a continuous, linear development in which three-dimensional tokens directly mapped onto two-dimensional ideograms with identical semantic values. However, recent reassessments indicate that this transition involved a profound conceptual fracture rather than a simple shift in medium. Whereas hollow bullae could only record transactions by physically enclosing a one-to-one quantity of tokens—rendering the internal contents invisible without breaking the outer seal—flat impressed tablets externalized both numerical quantity and commodity identity simultaneously. More importantly, while tokens conflated the counted object with the quantity (for example, five distinct ovoid tokens represented five jars of oil rather than an abstract concept of 'five' combined with a general symbol for 'oil'), proto-cuneiform scribes detached discrete numerical signs from commodity ideograms. Consequently, the development of early cuneiform was not merely a technological adaptation for storage efficiency, but a cognitive breakthrough enabling the abstract representation of quantity independent of physical commodities.

Based on the passage, which of the following assertions are logically supported by the text? (Select all that apply.)

  1. The method of using sealed bullae prevented administrators from visually inspecting the specific tokens enclosed without compromising the integrity of the container.Cevap
  2. B
    Mesopotamian administrators ceased the manufacturing and practical use of all three-dimensional clay tokens immediately upon the introduction of flat impressed tablets.
  3. Proto-cuneiform writing differed from the earlier token system by separating numerical quantification from the specific types of goods being recorded.Cevap
  4. D
    The emergence of proto-cuneiform in Uruk was primarily stimulated by the logistical demands of managing long-distance maritime trade across the Persian Gulf.
  5. E
    Flat impressed tablets represented transactions without retaining any semantic connection to earlier token-based record-keeping methods.

Cevap

The supported assertions are that sealed bullae prevented administrators from visually inspecting enclosed tokens without compromising the container's integrity, and that proto-cuneiform writing differed from the token system by separating numerical quantification from the specific types of goods being recorded.
The passage explicitly indicates that bullae enclosed tokens such that internal contents could not be seen without breaking the seal, directly supporting the statement concerning container integrity. Additionally, the passage contrasts token counting (which conflated quantity and object) with proto-cuneiform (which detached numerical signs from commodity ideograms), directly supporting the statement regarding the separation of quantification from commodity type.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the text regarding the physical characteristics and constraints of sealed bullae.
The text states that bullae enclosed tokens, rendering them invisible unless the outer seal was broken, confirming that physical inspection required compromising container integrity.
Direct textual deduction from the description of spherical clay envelopes.
2
Evaluate the cognitive distinction between token counting and proto-cuneiform script.
The passage highlights that scribes detached discrete numerical signs from commodity ideograms, whereas tokens conflated quantity with the object.
Logical synthesis of the author's argument regarding the conceptual transition to abstract numbers.
3
Eliminate unsupported claims involving unmentioned timelines, extraneous geographic/trade factors, and complete disconnections.
Unwarranted claims regarding immediate cessation of tokens, Persian Gulf maritime trade, and total semantic discontinuity are rejected.
Strict adherence to textual boundaries without importing outside facts or extreme extrapolations.

Anahtar Kavram

Drawing precise textual inferences and distinguishing necessary implications from unsupported extrapolations
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla