Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: ZorMust Be True / Most Strongly Supported

Premises:
- Every crop variety certified under the Alpine Biosecurity Protocol (ABP) is drought-tolerant.
- Any plant variety that produces anthocyanin pigmentation in its root tissue is not drought-tolerant.
- Most high-yield winter rye varieties certified under the ABP synthesize glucosinolates.
- No crop variety that synthesizes glucosinolates can be fertilized with nitrogen-heavy nitrates without undergoing cellular necrosis.

Statement to evaluate:
Based strictly on the premises above, at least some high-yield winter rye varieties certified under the ABP do not produce anthocyanin pigmentation in their root tissue and will undergo cellular necrosis if fertilized with nitrogen-heavy nitrates.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

True, because the premises establish a universal negative characteristic for all ABP-certified crops alongside a majority characteristic for ABP-certified winter rye, guaranteeing an existential overlap where both conditions hold.
The deduction combines a universal exclusion (derived via contrapositive) with a majority quantifier chain. Since 100% of ABP-certified crops lack root anthocyanin, any subset of ABP-certified crops—including the majority that experience necrosis under nitrate fertilization—must also lack root anthocyanin, strictly proving that at least some varieties exhibit both traits.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Derive the contrapositive from the relationship between root anthocyanin and drought tolerance.
Since Root Anthocyanin implies Not Drought-Tolerant, the contrapositive establishes that Drought-Tolerant implies No Root Anthocyanin.
To connect the root pigmentation condition to the ABP certification criteria.
2
Chain the universal premises regarding ABP certification.
ABP Certified implies Drought-Tolerant, which in turn implies No Root Anthocyanin. Thus, every ABP-certified variety (including all ABP-certified winter rye) lacks root anthocyanin.
To establish a universal property covering 100% of ABP-certified crops.
3
Synthesize the quantifier premise with the chemical sensitivity rule.
Most (>50%) ABP-certified high-yield winter rye varieties synthesize glucosinolates, and every glucosinolate synthesizer suffers cellular necrosis upon nitrogen-heavy nitrate fertilization. Therefore, most ABP-certified winter rye will undergo necrosis under these fertilization conditions.
To deduce the property held by the majority subset of the winter rye varieties.
4
Intersect the universal set property with the majority subset property.
The majority subset that undergoes necrosis is entirely contained within the universal set that lacks root anthocyanin. Consequently, at least some (specifically, a majority) possess both properties simultaneously.
To confirm that the quantified claim 'at least some' strictly must be true.

Anahtar Kavram

Quantifier Intersection and Contrapositive Deduction
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Must Be True / Most Strongly Supported

Bu konudan daha fazla soru