Soru

Zorluk: ZorMust Be True / Most Strongly Supported

Under Mediterranean maritime customary tribunals applying the Lex Rhodia doctrine, a shipmaster was permitted to enforce general average indemnification against cargo owners for emergency jettison of cargo during storms only if the vessel had passed an official seaworthiness inspection prior to departure and a majority of onboard merchant supercargoes voted to ratify the jettison. Furthermore, no tribunal would enforce an indemnification claim if the vessel carried unmanifested contraband goods during the voyage. Following a storm during an 842 CE voyage from Amalfi to Alexandria, the vessel Galatea lost cargo due to emergency jettison, and the maritime tribunal subsequently ordered the cargo owners to pay general average indemnification to the shipmaster.

Statement: Based on the facts established above, the Galatea was not carrying unmanifested contraband goods during the voyage, and a majority of the onboard merchant supercargoes ratified the jettison.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

True
The statement must be true because the tribunal's enforcement of the indemnification claim logically requires the satisfaction of all mandatory statutory conditions established in the premises: the absence of unmanifested contraband and the ratification by a majority of the supercargoes.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Formalize the conditional relationships stated in the stimulus.
Enforce Indemnification implies Seaworthiness Inspection, Majority Supercargo Ratification, and No Unmanifested Contraband.
The phrase 'only if' introduces necessary conditions, while the rule that 'no tribunal would enforce... if contraband was carried' establishes that carrying contraband is sufficient to preclude enforcement (Contraband implies No Indemnification; by contrapositive, Indemnification implies No Contraband).
2
Identify the verified factual outcome from the historical case.
The maritime tribunal formally ordered the cargo owners to pay general average indemnification.
This establishes that the sufficient condition for all necessary prerequisites has occurred.
3
Deduce the truth value of the compound statement.
Both conjuncts—that the vessel carried no unmanifested contraband and that a majority of supercargoes ratified the jettison—are logically guaranteed.
Because the necessary conditions must hold whenever the outcome is realized, the compound statement must be true.

Anahtar Kavram

Deductive Conditional Inference and Necessary Condition Fulfillment
Bu soruyu puanla