Soru

Zorluk: OrtaPerspective of Mentioned Groups

Read the following passage.

While classical economic models traditionally viewed environmental damage as an "external" cost to be managed through market pricing mechanisms, the discipline of ecological economics posits a fundamental paradigm shift. Neoclassical environmental economists maintain that natural capital and human-made capital are essentially interchangeable. From their perspective, the depletion of natural resources is not inherently problematic so long as the revenue generated is invested in producing equivalent human-made capital—a concept known as "weak sustainability." Therefore, they advocate for market-based solutions, such as carbon taxes or cap-and-trade systems, assuming that proper pricing will spur technological innovations capable of substituting for lost ecosystems.

Ecological economists, by contrast, argue for "strong sustainability." They contend that critical natural capital—such as the ozone layer, biodiversity, and global climate regulation—provides life-support functions that cannot be replicated or replaced by human technology. For ecological economists, the economic system is entirely a subsystem of the broader biosphere, rather than a parallel entity that occasionally interacts with the environment. Consequently, they view the reliance on pricing mechanisms as fundamentally flawed, because market prices cannot capture the absolute limits of ecological thresholds. Instead of merely correcting market failures, they advocate for strict biophysical constraints on economic scale and throughput, arguing that perpetual economic growth on a finite planet is a physical impossibility.

Based on the passage, neoclassical environmental economists would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements concerning technological innovation?

  1. It serves as a crucial mechanism that allows human-made capital to effectively replace diminished natural resources.Cevap
  2. B
    It cannot replicate the critical life-support functions provided by foundational environmental systems.
  3. C
    It will inevitably solve all future ecological crises, rendering biophysical constraints entirely unnecessary.
  4. D
    It provides a market-based solution that operates independently of pricing mechanisms like carbon taxes.
  5. E
    Its primary value lies in its ability to strictly limit the overall scale and throughput of the global economy.

Cevap

The correct answer is the option stating that technological innovation serves as a crucial mechanism that allows human-made capital to effectively replace diminished natural resources.
The passage explicitly notes that neoclassical environmental economists advocate for market solutions because they assume these will 'spur technological innovations capable of substituting for lost ecosystems.' Since they also believe natural capital and human-made capital are interchangeable, they view technology as the vehicle through which human-made capital can replace depleted natural resources.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the target group in the question stem.
The target group is 'neoclassical environmental economists'.
The passage discusses two distinct groups with opposing views. It is crucial to isolate the specific arguments attributed to the requested group.
2
Locate the textual evidence regarding the target group's view on technological innovation.
The text states neoclassical economists assume 'proper pricing will spur technological innovations capable of substituting for lost ecosystems' and believe natural and human-made capital are 'essentially interchangeable.'
Finding explicit textual support ensures the inference is strictly grounded in the passage rather than outside knowledge.
3
Evaluate the answer choices against this textual evidence.
The option affirming that technology allows human-made capital to replace diminished natural resources perfectly matches the 'substitution' and 'interchangeable' concepts attributed to this group.
Matching the conceptual meaning (even if paraphrased) confirms the correct answer while filtering out distractors.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying and contrasting the perspectives of distinct groups mentioned in a text.
Bu soruyu puanla