Soru

Zorluk: OrtaInferences from the Text

In reconstructing prehistoric pastoralist diets, archaeologists historically relied on faunal assemblages—examining animal bone wear and butchery marks—to infer whether ancient communities consumed dairy. However, such zooarchaeological markers cannot definitively establish whether milk was ingested, or whether herds were maintained solely for meat and traction. The recent application of paleoproteomic analysis to ancient dental calculus (calcified dental plaque) has substantially refined this inquiry. Dental calculus acts as a stable, mineralized matrix that traps salivary and dietary proteins over millennia, shielding them from the post-depositional hydrolytic degradation that typically destroys loose organic residues in soil. By using tandem mass spectrometry to isolate species-specific peptides—such as beta-lactoglobulin, a milk whey protein—researchers can directly identify the consumption of ruminant dairy products in individual skeletal remains. Crucially, while genomic DNA in archaeological skeletal material often undergoes severe fragmentation and contamination by environmental microbes, the dense mineral lattice of calculus preserves peptide bonds, permitting unambiguous identification of dairy proteins even in arid regions where bone collagen preservation is notoriously poor. Nevertheless, paleoproteomics alone cannot determine the specific culinary processing methods (such as fermentation into cheese or yogurt) that prehistoric populations used to mitigate adult lactose intolerance, because distinct processing techniques often yield identical degraded whey peptide fragments.

Based on the passage, which of the following statements are supported by the text? Select all that apply.

  1. The absence of well-preserved bone collagen at an arid archaeological site does not preclude the direct molecular detection of dairy consumption among its inhabitants.Cevap
  2. B
    Paleoproteomic analysis of dental calculus allows researchers to determine whether prehistoric pastoralists consumed milk in fermented rather than raw form.
  3. Relying exclusively on the physical analysis of butchered animal bones is insufficient to prove that a prehistoric community ingested dairy products.Cevap
  4. D
    Prehistoric pastoralist populations developed genetic lactase persistence before adopting ruminant dairying practices.
  5. E
    Tandem mass spectrometry relies primarily on extracting and sequencing fragments of environmental microbial DNA embedded in plaque.

Cevap

The statements confirming that poor bone collagen preservation at arid sites does not prevent direct molecular detection of dairy intake, and that physical analysis of butchered animal bones alone cannot definitively prove milk ingestion, are both logically supported by the passage.
The passage directly supports both valid statements: it confirms that faunal assemblages cannot definitively demonstrate dairy consumption (as herds might have been kept solely for meat or traction), and it notes that the dense mineral structure of dental calculus preserves peptides even under arid conditions where bone collagen degradation is severe.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the scope and explicit claims of the passage regarding traditional zooarchaeology and paleoproteomics.
The text establishes that faunal bone analyses cannot differentiate meat/traction use from dairy consumption, whereas dental calculus reliably preserves dairy peptides even in arid environments where bone collagen fails.
Accurate inference requires mapping each candidate statement directly against stated facts and logical entailments in the text.
2
Evaluate the validity of the supported statements against the passage text.
The statement regarding the feasibility of detecting dairy consumption despite poor bone collagen preservation is verified by the passage's discussion of calculus preservation in arid regions. The statement regarding the insufficiency of butchered animal bone analysis is verified by the passage's initial limitation on zooarchaeological markers.
Valid inferences in Reading Comprehension must follow necessarily from explicit textual premises without external leaps.
3
Eliminate unsupported statements and external claims.
Claims regarding fermentation determination contradict explicit text; claims about lactase persistence timing rely on outside knowledge; claims about DNA sequencing in mass spectrometry conflate protein analysis with DNA degradation.
Distractors exploit unsupported leaps, direct textual contradictions, and external real-world knowledge.

Anahtar Kavram

Drawing strictly bounded textual inferences regarding scientific methodology and analytical limitations from academic prose.
Tahmini Süre:1m 45s
Bu soruyu puanla