Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaIdentifying Analogous Situations

Proponents of the literary movement known as *Oulipo* advocated for writing under severe, self-imposed constraints—such as composing an entire novel without using the letter 'e'. They argued that unlimited artistic freedom often paralyzes the imagination by allowing writers to rely on comfortable clichés. In contrast, adhering to strict, arbitrary rules forces the mind to abandon habitual patterns and invent entirely novel modes of expression.

Which one of the following scenarios is most analogous to the dynamic between constraint and innovation as conceptualized by the proponents of *Oulipo*?

  1. A
    A novelist who abandons all traditional plot structures and grammar rules to ensure that their imagination is never paralyzed by arbitrary limitations.
  2. B
    A linguist who invents a new language containing only a few hundred words, hoping that it will become a highly efficient and universal tool for basic international communication.
  3. A chef who intentionally bans the use of salt and traditional cooking fats in their kitchen in order to compel their team to develop entirely new flavor-building techniques.Cevap
  4. D
    A student who argues that a teacher's highly rigid formatting requirements for a creative writing assignment inherently stifle their ability to explore the topic thoroughly.
  5. E
    A city planner who implements strict zoning regulations to prevent commercial developers from building structures that would alter the historical character of a neighborhood.

Cevap

The scenario describing a chef who intentionally bans salt and traditional fats to compel their team to develop new flavor techniques.
The correct answer accurately maps the three critical components of the passage's argument: 1) a self-imposed, severe constraint is introduced (banning essential ingredients), 2) this constraint is designed to prevent the use of standard, comfortable methods, and 3) the ultimate result is the forced invention of completely novel techniques. This perfectly parallels the literary movement's use of arbitrary rules to bypass clichés and foster novel artistic expression.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Abstract the core logical relationship from the passage.
The core dynamic is: [Self-imposed, severe constraint] → [Prevents reliance on habitual methods/clichés] → [Forces the invention of novel methods/expressions].
Analogous situations questions require matching the underlying abstract structure, not the topical subject matter.
2
Scan the options to eliminate those that rely on surface-level similarities or reverse the logic.
Eliminate the novelist option (reverses the logic regarding freedom vs. limitation) and the linguist option (matches language theme but targets efficiency, not forced innovation).
These are common traps designed to catch readers who focus on vocabulary rather than structural logic.
3
Evaluate the remaining options against all required elements of the abstracted logic.
The chef scenario matches perfectly: the ban is a self-imposed constraint, and its explicit purpose is to force the team out of habitual patterns to invent new flavor techniques.
All qualifying conditions (self-imposed, aiming for innovation rather than preservation or compliance) must align for the analogy to hold.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Analogous Situations
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Identifying Analogous Situations

Bu konudan daha fazla soru