Soru

Zorluk: OrtaExclusion Questions (EXCEPT/LEAST/NOT)

In 1856, while attempting to synthesize quinine to treat malaria, William Henry Perkin inadvertently created mauveine, the first synthetic organic dye. Prior to this serendipitous discovery, textile dyes were derived exclusively from natural sources such as insects, roots, and leaves. These traditional dyes were notoriously expensive to produce, limiting brightly colored textiles primarily to the wealthy elite. Furthermore, natural dyes were highly susceptible to fading when exposed to sunlight, rendering long-term color preservation nearly impossible. The commercial success of mauveine, synthesized from coal tar—a cheap waste product of the burgeoning coal gas industry—offered a stark contrast. It provided a vivid purple that was reliably reproducible, unlike natural dyes which often yielded inconsistent hues depending on the specific agricultural harvest. Ultimately, this transition not only democratized colored textiles but also laid the foundational infrastructure for the modern pharmaceutical industry.

Based on the passage, the author mentions all of the following as characteristics of dyes derived from natural sources EXCEPT:

  1. They were synthesized from the waste products of other industrial processes.Cevap
  2. B
    They were extracted solely from biological and botanical matter.
  3. C
    They required significant financial resources to manufacture.
  4. D
    They were vulnerable to losing their coloration when subjected to solar exposure.
  5. E
    They produced color results that fluctuated based on specific crop yields.

Cevap

The correct answer is the option stating that they were synthesized from the waste products of other industrial processes.
The correct answer incorrectly attributes a characteristic of synthetic dyes to natural dyes. The passage explicitly states that mauveine (the synthetic dye) was 'synthesized from coal tar—a cheap waste product of the burgeoning coal gas industry.' Natural dyes, by contrast, were derived from biological sources like insects and roots. Therefore, being synthesized from industrial waste is NOT a characteristic of natural dyes, making it the right answer to this EXCEPT question.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the question type and scope.
The capitalized 'EXCEPT' indicates an exclusion question. The scope is specifically limited to 'characteristics of dyes derived from natural sources.'
Establishing the precise parameters of the question prevents selecting an answer that is true for a different subject mentioned in the text.
2
Scan the passage for evidence regarding natural dyes.
The text lists several features: derived from insects/roots/leaves, expensive to produce, susceptible to fading in sunlight, and yielded inconsistent hues based on the harvest.
Gathering all explicit details allows for accurate elimination of the options that paraphrase these facts.
3
Evaluate the options to find the unmentioned or contradicted characteristic.
Four options accurately paraphrase the listed features of natural dyes. The remaining option describes being 'synthesized from waste products.' The passage attributes this feature (coal tar synthesis) strictly to the synthetic dye mauveine.
In an EXCEPT question, the correct answer is the one choice that is not supported by the passage for the specified subject.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying explicitly excluded details and avoiding viewpoint/subject misattribution.
Bu soruyu puanla