Soru

Zorluk: ZorCannot Be True Questions

According to international maritime records, any commercial vessel constructed after 2020 that is equipped with a dual-fuel engine is certified for zero-emission operations. Furthermore, no vessel is certified for zero-emission operations unless it utilizes a purely electric auxiliary power system. However, there are no commercial vessels built before 2025 that utilize purely electric auxiliary power systems.

If the statements above are true, which one of the following cannot be true?

  1. A commercial vessel constructed in 2024 is equipped with a dual-fuel engine.Cevap
  2. B
    A commercial vessel constructed in 2026 is equipped with a purely electric auxiliary power system but is not certified for zero-emission operations.
  3. C
    A commercial vessel certified for zero-emission operations was constructed in 2025 and is not equipped with a dual-fuel engine.
  4. D
    Most commercial vessels equipped with dual-fuel engines are not certified for zero-emission operations.
  5. E
    A non-commercial research vessel constructed in 2023 utilizes a purely electric auxiliary power system.

Cevap

The statement that a commercial vessel constructed in 2024 is equipped with a dual-fuel engine cannot be true, as it creates an impossible set of requirements.
Based on the rules provided, a commercial vessel constructed after 2020 with a dual-fuel engine absolutely must have a purely electric auxiliary power system. However, the final rule strictly forbids any commercial vessel built before 2025 from having this system. Therefore, any commercial vessel constructed in 2021, 2022, 2023, or 2024 is logically prohibited from having a dual-fuel engine.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Translate the first premise into conditional logic.
Commercial Vessel AND Constructed After 2020 AND Dual-Fuel Engine → Certified for Zero-Emission.
This establishes the sufficient condition that triggers the certification requirement.
2
Translate the second premise and link it to the first.
Certified for Zero-Emission → Purely Electric Auxiliary System. Therefore, Post-2020 Commercial Dual-Fuel → Purely Electric Auxiliary System.
The word 'unless' introduces a necessary condition, allowing us to form a deductive chain.
3
Analyze the third premise (the constraint).
Commercial Vessel AND Constructed Before 2025 → NOT (Purely Electric Auxiliary System).
This sets a hard boundary on when a commercial vessel can possess the electric system.
4
Evaluate the overlap between the deductive chain and the constraint.
A commercial vessel built between 2021 and 2024 with a dual-fuel engine MUST have an electric system (Step 2) but CANNOT have an electric system (Step 3).
Identifying the overlapping years (after 2020, but before 2025) reveals the logical impossibility that answers the 'Cannot Be True' question.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying a scenario that violates the necessary conclusion of a chained conditional statement combined with a categorical restriction.
Tahmini Süre:1m 45s
Bu soruyu puanla