A federal agency recently standardized its data security by implementing a new cryptograph… — LSAT

A federal agency recently standardized its data security by implementing a new cryptographic protocol across all its regional branches. Prior to this standardization, branches that independently utilized this specific cryptographic protocol reported the lowest incidence of unauthorized data access within the agency. The new mandate replaced all other security systems with this protocol. A post-implementation review revealed that, although the overall volume of unauthorized data access incidents across the agency fell by 40 percent, the specific branches that had previously utilized the weakest security systems experienced a marked increase in unauthorized access incidents following the protocol's implementation.

Which one of the following most accurately describes the apparent discrepancy presented in the review's findings?

A
The overall volume of unauthorized access incidents decreased by 40 percent agency-wide, despite a marked increase in such incidents at several specific regional branches.
B
The branches that previously utilized the weakest security systems were targeted more frequently by unauthorized users once they adopted the standardized cryptographic protocol.
The implementation of a security protocol previously correlated with the lowest incidence of unauthorized access coincided with an increased rate of unauthorized access in the branches that newly adopted it.Cevap
D
The 40 percent decrease in total agency-wide data access incidents contradicted the absolute increase in the number of breaches at the branches that previously had the weakest security.
E
The agency replaced all other security systems with a standardized cryptographic protocol, even though some branches previously utilized security systems of vastly differing strengths.

Cevap

The correct answer is the option stating that the implementation of a security protocol previously correlated with the lowest incidence of unauthorized access coincided with an increased rate of unauthorized access in the branches that newly adopted it.

The correct answer perfectly captures the essence of the paradox presented in the stimulus. The tension lies in the conflicting facts regarding the security protocol: it was historically associated with the best security outcomes, yet its implementation in the most vulnerable branches resulted in worse security outcomes for those specific branches. It describes the conflict purely based on the text without adding assumptions.

Adım Adım Çözüm

Analyze the stimulus to identify the core expectation established by the premises.

The stimulus establishes that the new cryptographic protocol is highly effective, as the branches originally using it had the lowest incidence of data breaches.

Identifying the baseline expectation is necessary to recognize why the subsequent outcome is surprising.

Identify the actual outcome that contradicts the established expectation.

When the branches with the weakest security systems adopted this highly effective protocol, their rate of unauthorized access incidents increased.

The discrepancy is the logical gap between the expected outcome (better security) and the actual outcome (worse security for specific branches).

Evaluate the answer choices to find the one that accurately describes this precise tension without attempting to explain it.

The correct choice succinctly summarizes the conflict between the protocol's prior successful track record and its counter-intuitive failure in the newly adopting branches.

In 'Identify the Discrepancy' questions, distractors often attempt to resolve the paradox or focus on irrelevant contrasts (such as the agency-wide decrease versus the local increase).

Anahtar Kavram

Isolating the core logical contradiction between an expected outcome based on historical performance and a surprising empirical result, without inadvertently selecting a resolution to the paradox.

Tahmini Süre:2m 30s

Soru

Cevap

Adım Adım Çözüm

Anahtar Kavram

Sık Yapılan Hatalar

Konular

Bu konudan daha fazla soru