Soru

Zorluk: ZorPerspective of Mentioned Groups

Read the following passage.

In the late nineteenth century, the American Institutionalist school of economics emerged as a robust challenge to classical economic orthodoxy. Classical economists posited a market driven by rational, utility-maximizing individuals operating within a framework of perfect information, naturally tending toward equilibrium. Institutionalists, conversely, argued that economic behavior is fundamentally shaped by evolving social conventions, embedded habits, and legal strictures—what they broadly termed "institutions." For Institutionalists, the classical reliance on deductive mathematical models was fundamentally misguided because such models necessarily abstracted away the idiosyncratic social realities governing human exchange. Instead, Institutionalists championed a descriptive, inductive approach rooted in historical observation.

Modern methodological critics of Institutionalism have frequently characterized the movement as theoretically adrift. These critics maintain that by substituting sociological description for mathematical generalization, Institutionalists sacrificed the discipline's predictive utility. From the perspective of these critics, because Institutionalism lacked a core set of unifying deductive axioms, it was relegated to merely cataloging past economic phenomena rather than providing a systematic apparatus capable of forecasting market responses to novel policy interventions.

Based on the passage, the "modern methodological critics of Institutionalism" would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements?

  1. A
    Integrating sociological observations into an economic framework will inevitably eliminate that framework's capacity for predictive forecasting.
  2. B
    Deductive mathematical models are valuable primarily because they deliberately abstract away the idiosyncratic social realities that complicate economic analysis.
  3. C
    In order to accurately understand economic phenomena, theorists must abandon generalized mathematical abstraction in favor of descriptive sociological observation.
  4. An economic theory's ability to systematically forecast market responses to new interventions requires a foundation of unifying deductive axioms.Cevap
  5. E
    The classical economic assumption of utility-maximizing individuals constitutes the only set of deductive axioms capable of effectively evaluating policy outcomes.

Cevap

The modern critics believe that an economic theory's ability to systematically forecast market responses to new interventions requires a foundation of unifying deductive axioms.
The correct answer is supported by the final sentence of the passage, which states that 'because Institutionalism lacked a core set of unifying deductive axioms, it was relegated to merely cataloging past economic phenomena rather than providing a systematic apparatus capable of forecasting.' This conditional phrasing logically implies that the critics believe unifying deductive axioms are a necessary foundation for any theory attempting to forecast market responses.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the target perspective in the text.
Located the views of the 'modern methodological critics of Institutionalism' in the second paragraph.
The question specifically asks for an inference regarding this particular group's beliefs.
2
Analyze the group's core argument and logic.
The critics argue that substituting sociological description for mathematical generalization cost the discipline its predictive utility. Specifically, because Institutionalism lacked 'unifying deductive axioms,' it failed to provide a framework capable of 'forecasting market responses.'
Understanding the cause-and-effect relationship proposed by the group is essential for determining what they would agree with.
3
Evaluate the answer choices based strictly on this logic.
The correct choice must logically reflect that a lack of deductive axioms prevents predictive forecasting, meaning those axioms are necessary for forecasting.
LSAT inference questions require selecting an option that is a deductively valid translation of the passage's explicit statements.

Anahtar Kavram

Perspective of Mentioned Groups
Bu soruyu puanla