Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorEliminating One-Sided Explanations

Veridium Industries recently installed a new automated quality-control system for the raw components used in its smartphone assembly plant. This new system detects and discards defective components with 99.9 percent accuracy, successfully eliminating almost all pre-existing component flaws before assembly. However, over the following year, the percentage of fully assembled smartphones failing the standard post-assembly functionality tests due to hardware defects actually increased by 20 percent, even though the final assembly procedures, the workforce, and the post-assembly testing standards remained entirely unchanged.

Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?

  1. A
    The automated quality-control system utilizes advanced laser-scanning technology that identifies microscopic structural anomalies that were completely invisible to the human inspectors who previously checked the components.
  2. B
    Consumers who purchase newly released smartphones are generally more critical of minor performance issues and are more likely to report hardware defects than consumers who purchase older models.
  3. The automated quality-control system relies on intense magnetic fields that inadvertently magnetize certain metallic components, causing them to short-circuit only when connected to the smartphone's power supply during final testing.Cevap
  4. D
    Because the automated inspection process requires far less time than manual inspection, Veridium Industries was able to increase its total daily production of fully assembled smartphones by nearly 40 percent.
  5. E
    To guarantee the highest possible quality, the new automated system is programmed to aggressively discard any component that shows even the slightest deviation from optimal manufacturing specifications.

Cevap

The option stating that the automated system relies on intense magnetic fields that inadvertently magnetize components, causing them to short-circuit during final testing.
The correct answer provides a mechanism that bridges both sides of the discrepancy. It accepts Premise A (the system successfully removes pre-existing flaws) but introduces a critical new variable: the system itself creates a latent defect (magnetization). Because this latent defect only causes a short-circuit when the phone is finally powered on during the post-assembly test, it perfectly explains why the final failure rate increased (Premise B) despite the components being 'flawless' when they originally entered the assembly line.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the first conflicting premise (Premise A).
The new automated QC system successfully eliminates 99.9% of pre-existing component flaws before the components are assembled into smartphones.
Understanding the baseline expectation helps frame the paradox.
2
Identify the second conflicting premise (Premise B).
Despite the nearly perfect components entering assembly, the percentage of fully assembled smartphones failing final hardware tests increased by 20%, with no changes to the assembly process itself.
This establishes the unexpected outcome that contradicts the baseline expectation.
3
Define the precise nature of the discrepancy.
If components are entering the assembly process flawless, and the assembly process itself has not changed, how can there be a 20% increase in hardware defects at the final testing stage?
A clear definition of the gap is required to evaluate the answer choices accurately.
4
Evaluate the options for a bridging mechanism.
The correct answer must explain how a new defect is introduced either during or after the QC process, but before or during the final functionality test.
Only an option that addresses both the 'flawless input' and the 'flawed output' can resolve the paradox.
5
Select the correct option.
The option involving magnetic fields explains that the QC machine itself creates a latent defect (magnetization) that bypasses the assembly process undetected but triggers a failure during the final power test.
This perfectly reconciles the flawless initial state with the increased final failure rate.

Anahtar Kavram

Eliminating One-Sided Explanations
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Eliminating One-Sided Explanations

Bu konudan daha fazla soru