Soru

Zorluk: KolayEvaluating the Degree of Commitment or Certainty

Biologists have long debated the primary function of the zebra's stripes. Early researchers confidently asserted that the pattern served as camouflage against predators in the tall savanna grass. Modern field studies, however, present a compelling case for a different mechanism. The data strongly indicate that the striking black-and-white pattern functions primarily to deter biting flies, which are known to avoid landing on striped surfaces. While other secondary benefits cannot be entirely ruled out, the fly-deterrence hypothesis currently offers the most robust explanation for this evolutionary adaptation.

Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's degree of commitment to the fly-deterrence hypothesis?

  1. Firm endorsement of the hypothesis as the most well-supported explanation, while conceding that stripes might still serve other minor purposes.Cevap
  2. B
    Absolute certainty that the fly-deterrence hypothesis is the only valid scientific explanation for zebra stripes.
  3. C
    Neutral detachment, presenting the hypothesis simply as one of several equally unproven theories.
  4. D
    Objective reporting of modern researchers' views, carefully avoiding any personal endorsement of the hypothesis.
  5. E
    Unqualified and dogmatic assertion, mirroring the unyielding certainty of the early researchers mentioned in the text.

Cevap

Firm endorsement of the hypothesis as the most well-supported explanation, while conceding that stripes might still serve other minor purposes.
The correct answer accurately synthesizes two aspects of the passage. First, the author's use of phrases like 'compelling case', 'strongly indicate', and 'most robust explanation' demonstrates a firm endorsement of the fly-deterrence hypothesis. Second, the explicit caveat that 'other secondary benefits cannot be entirely ruled out' proves the author is carefully conceding that stripes might have other, minor purposes.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the text for tone-revealing adjectives and adverbs expressing the author's viewpoint.
The author uses 'compelling case', 'strongly indicate', and 'most robust explanation'.
These phrases establish the baseline level of commitment: the author heavily favors and endorses the fly-deterrence hypothesis.
2
Scan the text for qualifiers or limitations placed on the primary viewpoint.
The author includes the clause 'While other secondary benefits cannot be entirely ruled out...'
This sets the boundary of the author's certainty, proving they stop short of absolute, 100% certainty regarding exclusivity.
3
Synthesize the findings to select the description that matches both the high confidence and the presence of a qualifier.
The correct description must balance 'firm endorsement' with an acknowledgment of 'other minor purposes'.
Correctly identifying an author's degree of commitment requires capturing both their support for a theory and the precise limitations they place on that support.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating the Degree of Commitment or Certainty
Tahmini Süre:1m 0s
Bu soruyu puanla