Soru

Zorluk: ZorMost Strongly Supported Questions

Recent isotopic analyses of bronze artifacts found in the ancient city of Kanesh indicate that the copper used in their production was mined exclusively from the Ergani region, located to the east. However, the tin used in these same artifacts bears an isotopic signature matching mines in the distant west, far beyond the established trade networks of Kanesh's empire. Written records from Kanesh detail extensive trade with the east, but they contain no mention of any trade routes extending to the western regions where the tin originated.

Based on the information above, the following statement is most strongly supported:

The written records of Kanesh must be incomplete because they fail to document the city's direct trade with the western tin mines.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

The statement is False because it assumes direct trade occurred, which is a leap in logic not supported by the premises.
The statement is not strongly supported because it assumes the existence of 'direct trade' between Kanesh and the western mines. The stimulus only proves that the tin originated in the west; it is entirely possible that Kanesh acquired the tin through intermediary merchants, meaning the written records might be perfectly complete and accurate despite omitting direct western routes.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the premises provided in the stimulus.
Premise 1: Copper came from the east. Premise 2: Tin came from the distant west. Premise 3: Kanesh records detail eastern trade but do not mention western trade routes.
To establish the factual boundaries of what can be proven based strictly on the text.
2
Examine the statement to be evaluated.
The statement claims the records are incomplete due to a failure to document 'direct trade' with the western tin mines.
To identify the exact claim being tested for support and isolate any new concepts introduced.
3
Compare the statement's claims against the established premises.
The premises confirm the geographic origin of the tin but do not establish the method of acquisition. The statement introduces the concept of 'direct trade', which is not mentioned or necessitated by the premises.
To determine if the statement logically follows from the text without requiring outside assumptions.

Anahtar Kavram

Evaluating whether a conclusion introduces unwarranted outside information or assumptions not strictly supported by the premises.
Bu soruyu puanla