Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaBridging Conflicting Premises

A city introduced a substantial congestion charge aimed at reducing the number of passenger vehicles entering the downtown area during peak hours. However, six months after the charge's implementation, the number of passenger vehicles entering the downtown area during peak hours had actually increased by 15 percent.

The apparent discrepancy is successfully resolved by the additional fact that surveys show most downtown commuters consider the new congestion charge to be a severe financial burden.

Cevap: Cevap

Cevap

False
The proposed statement is false because the additional fact does not bridge the gap between the premises; instead, it makes the discrepancy even more baffling. If the congestion charge is viewed as a severe financial burden, one would naturally expect commuters to seek alternatives, leading to a decrease in traffic. Because the fact does not explain the unexpected increase in vehicles, it fails to serve as a valid resolution.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the two conflicting premises in the stimulus.
Premise 1: A substantial congestion charge was introduced to reduce peak-hour traffic. Premise 2: Peak-hour traffic actually increased by 15 percent.
Resolving a paradox requires first isolating the exact nature of the apparent contradiction.
2
Determine the necessary role of a resolving fact.
A valid resolution must provide a contextual mechanism showing why traffic increased despite the intentional financial penalty.
The correct additional premise must allow both original facts to be simultaneously true without invalidating either one.
3
Evaluate the proposed resolution's impact on the paradox.
The fact that commuters find the charge to be a severe financial burden gives them an even stronger incentive to stop driving. Thus, the traffic increase becomes even more surprising.
A fact that makes an outcome more contradictory is a paradox-deepening trap, not a valid resolution.

Anahtar Kavram

Bridging Conflicting Premises
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Bridging Conflicting Premises

Bu konudan daha fazla soru