Soru

Zorluk: OrtaStrengthen

A recent dietary survey found that individuals who regularly consume fermented foods, such as yogurt and kimchi, report significantly lower levels of daily stress than those who rarely eat such foods. Based on this correlation, nutrition researchers concluded that the specific probiotics prevalent in fermented foods actively reduce the body's physiological stress response.

Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the researchers' argument?

  1. In a subsequent controlled trial, individuals randomly assigned to consume fermented foods daily showed a substantial decrease in blood cortisol, a primary stress hormone.Cevap
  2. B
    People who experience high levels of chronic stress often lack the free time and energy required to prepare or seek out fermented foods.
  3. C
    Among individuals who consume fermented foods regularly, those who eat the greatest variety of such foods report the lowest levels of daily stress.
  4. D
    The people in the dietary survey who rarely ate fermented foods consumed a higher total number of calories than those who ate them regularly.
  5. E
    The percentage of the population consuming fermented foods has steadily increased over the last year, even though the absolute number of stress-related medical visits has not.

Cevap

The statement detailing a controlled trial where randomly assigned consumption of fermented foods led to a decrease in blood cortisol.
The correct answer strengthens the conclusion by shifting from observational survey data to a controlled experimental trial. By randomly assigning the diet and showing a measurable physiological result (decreased blood cortisol), it establishes a clear timeline and eliminates alternative lifestyle factors, directly supporting the claim that probiotics actively cause a reduction in stress.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the argument's premises and main conclusion.
Premise: Survey shows a correlation between eating fermented foods and lower stress. Conclusion: Probiotics in fermented foods actively reduce the body's stress response.
Deconstructing the argument is necessary to pinpoint the exact logical leap being made.
2
Identify the logical gap or vulnerability in the reasoning.
The researchers assume causation based entirely on correlation. They fail to account for alternative causes or reverse causation (e.g., less stressed people having better diets).
Finding the flaw reveals what type of evidence is needed to strengthen the claim.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to find one that bridges the gap.
The correct answer provides a randomized controlled trial showing a direct physiological effect (decreased cortisol) following the introduction of fermented foods.
Controlled experiments eliminate confounding variables and reverse causation, providing the strongest possible support for a causal conclusion.

Anahtar Kavram

Strengthening Causal Arguments (Ruling Out Alternatives / Confirming Mechanism)
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular