Soru

Zorluk: KolayLogical Inferences

In architectural conservation, researchers analyzed medieval stained glass windows to understand their durability. They found that glass containing high concentrations of sodium and calcium is highly susceptible to corrosion when exposed to atmospheric moisture, which reacts with sodium to form a silica-degrading alkaline film. However, glass composed primarily of potassium and lead shows almost no surface degradation under identical environmental conditions. Since potassium-lead glass does not readily react with moisture to form this alkaline film, ______

Which choice most logically completes the text?

  1. A
    medieval artisans deliberately selected potassium and lead to ensure their windows would last for centuries.
  2. it is less likely to undergo moisture-induced silica degradation than sodium-calcium glass is.Cevap
  3. C
    any glass containing potassium and lead will remain entirely free from all forms of chemical weathering.
  4. D
    sodium-calcium glass is more durable than potassium-lead glass when exposed to high levels of humidity.

Cevap

it is less likely to undergo moisture-induced silica degradation than sodium-calcium glass is.
The correct option is supported because the passage outlines a direct causal chain for sodium-calcium glass: exposure to moisture leads to a reaction forming an alkaline film, which in turn degrades the silica. Because potassium-lead glass is shown not to undergo this reaction, it logically follows that it is less susceptible to this specific process of silica degradation.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the premises regarding sodium-calcium glass.
Sodium-calcium glass reacts with atmospheric moisture to form an alkaline film that degrades the silica network.
This establishes the mechanism of degradation for one type of glass.
2
Identify the premises regarding potassium-lead glass.
Potassium-lead glass shows almost no degradation and does not react with moisture to form the degrading alkaline film.
This contrasts the behavior of the two glass types under identical conditions.
3
Draw the logical completion of the text based on these premises.
Because potassium-lead glass avoids the reaction that initiates silica degradation, it is less susceptible to this specific type of moisture-induced damage compared to sodium-calcium glass.
This completes the logical argument without introducing outside assumptions.

Anahtar Kavram

Drawing logical inferences from comparative premises
Bu soruyu puanla