Soru

Zorluk: OrtaParallel Structure

Which word completes the passage so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

Cevap:In his study of ancient agricultural practices, archaeologist Liam O'Connor argues that the transition to farming in the Fertile Crescent was motivated not by a sudden climatic shift but 【by】 a gradual decline in wild food resources. According to O'Connor, early hunter-gatherers were forced to cultivate crops as their traditional foraging grounds became depleted, demonstrating that necessity, rather than choice, drove agricultural innovation.

Cevap

by
The correct answer is 'by'. The sentence uses the contrastive construction 'not [X] but [Y]' to contrast two potential causes of the agricultural transition. To maintain parallel structure, the grammatical form of both parts of the contrast must be identical. Because the first part of the contrast is a prepositional phrase introduced by the preposition 'by' ('not by a sudden climatic shift'), the second part must also be a prepositional phrase introduced by the same preposition ('but by a gradual decline').

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the parallel elements and grammatical structures in the sentence.
The sentence presents a contrast using the structure 'not [element 1] but [element 2]'. The first element is 'by a sudden climatic shift'.
Recognizing the parallel construction helps determine the grammatical pattern required for the second element.
2
Analyze the grammatical structure of the first element.
The phrase 'by a sudden climatic shift' is a prepositional phrase headed by the preposition 'by'.
Parallel structure requires that elements joined by coordinating or correlative conjunctions have the same grammatical form.
3
Complete the second element to match the first.
The second element must also be a prepositional phrase headed by the preposition 'by', resulting in 'by a gradual decline'.
Using the preposition 'by' after 'but' ensures that both elements are grammatically parallel.

Anahtar Kavram

Parallel Structure with Prepositional Phrases
Bu soruyu puanla