Soru

Zorluk: ZorCommand of Evidence: Textual

In the extreme environments of deep-sea hydrothermal vents, the giant tube worm *Riftia pachyptila* relies entirely on a symbiotic relationship with chemolithoautotrophic bacteria housed in an organ called the trophosome. These bacteria oxidize hydrogen sulfide (H2S\text{H}_2\text{S}) from the vent fluid to produce organic molecules for the worm. Biologist Dr. Sunita Alvarez hypothesized that the metabolic rate of these endosymbiotic bacteria is primarily regulated by the availability of dissolved H2S\text{H}_2\text{S} in the surrounding water rather than by fluctuations in the ambient water temperature. Alvarez and her team monitored several *Riftia pachyptila* colonies near a vent field in the East Pacific Rise, recording bacterial metabolic activity under varying environmental conditions.

Which choice, if true, would most directly support Alvarez's hypothesis?

  1. A
    Colonies of *Riftia pachyptila* that were positioned farther from the main hydrothermal vent opening developed larger trophosomes than those positioned closer to the vent, allowing them to host a greater overall volume of bacteria.
  2. B
    Bacterial metabolic rates fluctuated in direct correlation with hourly temperature shifts in the vent field, even when the concentration of dissolved H2S\text{H}_2\text{S} in the surrounding water was artificially held constant.
  3. The metabolic rate of the endosymbiotic bacteria remained stable during a period of localized volcanic heating that raised the ambient water temperature by 8C8^\circ\text{C}, but declined sharply when hydrothermal fluid flow decreased and reduced the local concentration of dissolved H2S\text{H}_2\text{S}.Cevap
  4. D
    Symbiotic bacteria residing in shallow-water organisms likely depend on similar environmental triggers to regulate host metabolic rates, suggesting a shared evolutionary origin with deep-sea symbionts.

Cevap

The correct answer is the statement that the metabolic rate of the endosymbiotic bacteria remained stable during temperature shifts but declined when the concentration of dissolved hydrogen sulfide decreased.
The correct option is the statement that the metabolic rate remained stable during temperature changes but declined when hydrogen sulfide levels fell. This directly validates the researcher's hypothesis by demonstrating that metabolic rate shifts in response to hydrogen sulfide levels rather than temperature variations, effectively isolating the independent variables.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the main hypothesis to be supported.
The hypothesis is that the metabolic rate of endosymbiotic bacteria in *Riftia pachyptila* is regulated by dissolved hydrogen sulfide concentration, not by ambient water temperature fluctuations.
This establishes the target relationship that the supporting evidence must validate.
2
Determine the necessary evidence profile to validate this hypothesis.
The correct evidence must demonstrate that changing the temperature while keeping hydrogen sulfide stable has no effect on metabolism, whereas changing hydrogen sulfide levels results in direct metabolic changes.
This isolates the independent variables (temperature and hydrogen sulfide concentration) to show which one is the true regulator of the dependent variable (bacterial metabolic rate).
3
Evaluate the choices against this evidence profile.
The statement describing stable metabolic rates during an 8C8^\circ\text{C} temperature increase but sharp declines when hydrogen sulfide concentration drops perfectly matches this requirement.
This confirms that hydrogen sulfide is the active regulatory factor while temperature is not.

Anahtar Kavram

Command of Evidence: Textual
Bu soruyu puanla