**Text 1** Beaver reintroduction programs are increasingly promoted as a primary, low-cost… — SAT

Text 1
Beaver reintroduction programs are increasingly promoted as a primary, low-cost method for restoring degraded freshwater ecosystems. Proponents highlight that the physical dams constructed by beaver colonies reduce stream velocity, decrease erosion, and create wetland habitats that support a wide range of aquatic and terrestrial species. By recharging groundwater reservoirs and raising local water tables, beaver dams are believed to buffer vulnerable riparian ecosystems against drought, thereby establishing self-sustaining environments that require minimal ongoing human management or intervention.

Text 2
Ecologist Sarah Vance and her colleagues agree that beaver dams can increase localized biodiversity in the short term, but they caution against viewing reintroduction as a comprehensive ecological cure-all. Their research indicates that in many stream systems, beaver dams block critical migration routes for native fish and trap sediment to the point of altering downstream nutrient flows. Additionally, the impounded water behind dams can absorb solar radiation, raising stream temperatures to levels that threaten sensitive cold-water species. Thus, Vance argues that without careful, case-by-case site assessment and active human oversight, reintroductions can degrade habitats for the very species conservationists aim to protect.

Based on the passages, how would the author of Text 2 most likely characterize the view of the "proponents" presented in Text 1?

As overly generalized because it neglects how stream-specific variables can necessitate continuous human monitoring and management.Cevap
B
As completely unfounded because beaver dams do not actually provide long-term benefits to terrestrial or aquatic wildlife.
C
As scientifically flawed because it exaggerates the degree to which beaver dams can slow stream velocity and reduce erosion.
D
As highly accurate because both texts agree that beaver reintroduction is the most cost-effective method for ecological restoration.

Cevap

The author of Text 2 would most likely characterize the proponents' view as overly generalized because it neglects how stream-specific variables can necessitate continuous human monitoring and management.

The proponents in Text 1 claim that beaver reintroductions establish self-sustaining environments that require minimal ongoing human management. In contrast, the author of Text 2 points out that beaver dams can cause negative ecological consequences—such as blocking fish migrations, trapping sediment, and warming streams—and argues that active human oversight and site-by-site assessments are required. Therefore, the author of Text 2 would view the proponents' claims as overly generalized because they fail to account for the situations where human management and monitoring are necessary.

Adım Adım Çözüm

Analyze the proponents' claim in Text 1.

The proponents in Text 1 argue that beaver dams create self-sustaining environments that require minimal ongoing human management or intervention.

To understand the perspective that the author of Text 2 is responding to.

Analyze the response and findings of the author of Text 2.

The author of Text 2 (Sarah Vance) argues that beaver dams can have negative impacts (blocking fish migration, trapping sediment, raising water temperatures) and require careful, case-by-case site assessment and active human oversight to prevent habitat degradation.

To identify the points of disagreement or qualification between the two authors.

Compare the two perspectives to determine how the author of Text 2 would view the proponents' claim.

Since Text 1 claims the dams create self-sustaining systems with minimal human management, and Text 2 argues that active human oversight and case-by-case assessments are critical to avoid ecological harm, the author of Text 2 would characterize the proponents' view as overly generalized.

To match the relationship between the texts with the correct multiple-choice option.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying perspective and relational stance between two passages discussing the same topic.

Soru

Cevap

Adım Adım Çözüm

Anahtar Kavram

Sık Yapılan Hatalar

Konular

Bu konudan daha fazla soru