Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCross-Text Connections: Perspective Comparison

Text 1
Many paleontologists argue that the prominent neural spine sail of the dinosaur *Spinosaurus* functioned primarily as a thermoregulatory structure. According to this view, the massive sail allowed the creature to absorb or dissipate heat in its semi-aquatic environment. Researchers point to the extensive network of vascular grooves on the fossilized spines as evidence of active blood flow, which would have facilitated rapid heat exchange. Under this hypothesis, the sail was a crucial physiological adaptation for survival in a hot, Cretaceous climate.

Text 2
Conversely, paleontologist Dr. Maya Lin contends that the thermoregulatory hypothesis is biologically implausible. Lin notes that modern semi-aquatic apex predators, such as crocodilians, regulate their body temperatures effectively without specialized dorsal sails. Instead, Lin proposes that the sail served a visual display function, signaling maturity to potential mates and rivals. She argues that the vascular grooves observed in the fossils are merely byproducts of rapid skeletal growth during adolescence, rather than evidence of a dedicated heat-exchange system.

Based on the texts, how would Dr. Lin (Text 2) most likely characterize the 'vascular grooves' cited by the paleontologists in Text 1?

  1. A
    As a physiological feature that confirms the close evolutionary relationship between *Spinosaurus* and modern crocodilians
  2. B
    As a misidentified fossil structure that does not actually exist in *Spinosaurus* specimens
  3. As a growth-related skeletal feature rather than evidence of a functional heat-dissipation systemCevap
  4. D
    As a specialized sensory mechanism that allowed the dinosaur to navigate semi-aquatic habitats

Cevap

As a growth-related skeletal feature rather than evidence of a functional heat-dissipation system
The correct answer is correct because Dr. Lin argues in Text 2 that the vascular grooves are byproducts of adolescent skeletal growth rather than proof of a heat-exchange system, which directly refutes the thermoregulatory hypothesis proposed by the paleontologists in Text 1.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the paleontologists' claim in Text 1 regarding the 'vascular grooves'.
The paleontologists view the vascular grooves as evidence of active blood flow supporting a thermoregulatory (heat-exchange) function.
To establish the baseline arguments of Text 1.
2
Analyze Dr. Lin's counter-claim in Text 2 regarding these grooves.
Dr. Lin states that these grooves are 'byproducts of rapid skeletal growth during adolescence' rather than adaptations for heat exchange.
To determine how the author of Text 2 characterizes the specific evidence from Text 1.
3
Compare Dr. Lin's view with the options to find the correct paraphrase.
The option stating the grooves are growth-related skeletal features aligns perfectly with Dr. Lin's argument.
To select the correct response.

Anahtar Kavram

Cross-Text Connections: Perspective Comparison
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla