Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCommand of Evidence: Textual

Although the sudden prevalence of cobalt blue glaze in eighth-century Chinese Tang dynasty ceramics is often attributed solely to the opening of new Silk Road trade routes that made the raw pigment accessible, art historian Dr. Julian Sterling argues that this adoption was also heavily dependent on local technological innovations. Specifically, Sterling claims that the successful use of cobalt glaze required the development of specialized high-firing reduction kilns capable of stabilizing the mineral; without these specific kilns, the cobalt would run or discolor during firing. Thus, Sterling argues that areas without these technological upgrades could not adopt cobalt blue, regardless of pigment availability. Which finding, if true, would most directly support Sterling's argument?

  1. During the eighth century, ceramic workshops in regions with direct access to imported cobalt but lacking high-firing reduction kilns produced no cobalt-glazed wares, whereas workshops that constructed these kilns immediately began producing them.Cevap
  2. B
    Eighth-century trade records indicate that the market value of cobalt-glazed ceramics was significantly higher than that of ceramics glazed with locally sourced copper or iron.
  3. C
    Chemical analyses of cobalt glazes from the eighth century reveal that the imported cobalt contained trace impurities of manganese, which would have made it highly unstable under any firing conditions.
  4. D
    Excavations of eighth-century kilns show that older oxidizing kilns were far cheaper to construct and operate than the newer high-firing reduction kilns.

Cevap

The correct answer is the option stating that eighth-century workshops in regions with cobalt access but lacking reduction kilns produced no cobalt wares, while those with the kilns did.
The correct answer supports the argument by showing a clear correlation between the presence of the technological innovation (high-firing reduction kilns) and the adoption of cobalt-glazed ceramics, even when pigment access is held constant. This demonstrates that the technology was indeed a determining factor, as the argument claims.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify Dr. Sterling's core claim in the passage.
Sterling claims that the adoption of cobalt blue glaze was not just due to trade access, but required local high-firing reduction kilns to stabilize the glaze.
To support the argument, we must find evidence that directly connects the use of cobalt glaze to the presence of the kiln technology, showing that access to the pigment alone was insufficient.
2
Evaluate the options to find one that links kiln technology directly to cobalt glaze production.
The option comparing workshops with and without the kilns (despite both having pigment access) shows that only those with the kilns could produce the cobalt-glazed wares.
This comparison isolates the kiln technology as the critical factor for adopting the glaze, supporting Sterling's claim.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying textual evidence that supports a specific research hypothesis or claim.
Bu soruyu puanla