Soru

Zorluk: OrtaCross-Text Connections: Perspective Comparison

Text 1
Many evolutionary biologists and behavioral economists have argued that the endowment effect—the tendency to value an item more highly simply because one owns it—is an ancient evolutionary adaptation. In a series of experiments, researcher Sarah Brosnan and colleagues demonstrated that chimpanzees (Pan troglodytesPan\ troglodytes) exhibit a strong preference for keeping food items they already possess (such as peanut butter) over trading them for alternative foods of equal value (like fruit juice). Brosnan concludes that this bias is deeply ingrained, serving to minimize the risk of losing resources in unstable social environments where possession is the primary guarantor of ownership.

Text 2
Behavioral scientist Michael Tomasello challenges the view that the endowment effect in non-human primates is an innate evolutionary bias. Tomasello points out that chimpanzees in Brosnan’s experiments were tested in highly artificial, isolated laboratory settings. In natural group settings, chimpanzees frequently engage in food sharing and competitive theft, where holding onto an item does not guarantee its security. Tomasello argues that Brosnan's findings reflect a temporary strategy learned within the structured confines of human-controlled testing rather than a hardwired evolutionary adaptation that dictates wild chimpanzee behavior.

Based on Text 2, how would Tomasello most likely characterize the chimpanzees' reluctance to trade food items in Brosnan's experiments?

  1. A
    As an instinctual survival mechanism that is even more pronounced in wild populations than in laboratory settings
  2. B
    As a demonstration of cognitive reasoning and cooperation rather than a basic resource-retention bias
  3. As a context-specific behavior learned in captivity rather than an inherent evolutionary traitCevap
  4. D
    As a direct response to the threat of food theft from other chimpanzees in the laboratory

Cevap

As a context-specific behavior learned in captivity rather than an inherent evolutionary trait
The correct answer accurately reflects Tomasello's perspective. In Text 2, Tomasello argues that the chimpanzees' behavior in the laboratory is a temporary strategy learned in an artificial, human-controlled environment. He contrasts this with natural settings where food sharing and theft are common, showing that he views the reluctance to trade as a context-specific response to laboratory conditions rather than an innate evolutionary adaptation as Brosnan claims.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify Brosnan's claim in Text 1 regarding the chimpanzees' behavior.
Brosnan argues that the chimpanzees' reluctance to trade food represents the endowment effect, which she characterizes as an ingrained evolutionary adaptation for resource retention.
This establishes the baseline perspective that Text 2 responds to.
2
Analyze Tomasello's critique in Text 2.
Tomasello argues that the behavior is not evolutionary but is a temporary strategy learned within the artificial confines of isolated laboratory settings.
This provides the contrasting viewpoint needed to answer the question.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that matches Tomasello's view.
The option stating the behavior is context-specific and learned in captivity rather than an inherent evolutionary trait matches Tomasello's characterization.
It accurately captures the contrast between Tomasello's focus on laboratory conditions and Brosnan's focus on evolutionary biology.

Anahtar Kavram

Cross-Text Connections: Perspective Comparison
Bu soruyu puanla