Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorCentral Ideas

In evolutionary biology, the concept of "niche construction"—whereby organisms actively modify their environments—has challenged the traditional, unidirectional model of natural selection. Standard evolutionary theory posits that adaptation is a passive response to external ecological pressures. In contrast, proponents of niche construction argue that by altering their surroundings, organisms co-direct their own evolutionary trajectories. Yet, critics caution that overemphasizing this phenomenon risks conflating the proximate causes of environmental modification with the ultimate causes of evolutionary change. They argue that the capacity to modify the environment is itself an adaptation shaped by prior natural selection, meaning that niche construction remains subordinate to, rather than independent of, classical selective forces.

Which choice best states the main idea of the text?

  1. A
    The debate over niche construction highlights the ongoing difficulty scientists face when trying to define what constitutes an evolutionary adaptation.
  2. B
    Proponents of niche construction believe that organisms adapt passively to their environments, whereas traditional theorists argue that organisms actively shape their surroundings.
  3. While niche construction is proposed as a way for organisms to co-direct their evolution, critics argue that the behavior is ultimately secondary to traditional natural selection since the ability to modify environments is itself an evolved trait.Cevap
  4. D
    Critics of niche construction reject the idea that organisms modify their environments, arguing that such behavior has no impact on ecological conditions.

Cevap

While niche construction is proposed as a way for organisms to co-direct their evolution, critics argue that the behavior is ultimately secondary to traditional natural selection since the ability to modify environments is itself an evolved trait.
The correct answer accurately states the main conflict and resolution of the passage: it acknowledges that proponents view niche construction as a co-directing evolutionary force, but highlights the critics' primary argument that niche construction is ultimately subordinate to traditional natural selection because environmental modification is itself an evolved trait.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Read the passage to identify the main topic and the primary perspectives presented.
The passage discusses niche construction (organisms modifying their environments), presenting a conflict between proponents (who say it co-directs evolution) and critics (who argue it is subordinate to natural selection).
Understanding the overall structure of the passage helps locate where the author shifts from presenting a theory to discussing its critique.
2
Analyze the critics' argument at the end of the passage.
Critics argue that the capacity to modify the environment is an adaptation shaped by prior natural selection, making niche construction subordinate to classical selective forces.
The passage culminates in this critique, which qualifies the claims of the proponents and shapes the core message of the text.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that summarizes both the proponents' view and the critics' subordinate counterargument.
The correct choice accurately synthesizes the idea that niche construction is proposed to co-direct evolution but is argued by critics to be secondary to natural selection.
This aligns with the central idea of the entire text, while other options are too broad, factually incorrect, or unsupported.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying the central idea of a passage that presents opposing scientific arguments.
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Central Ideas

Bu konudan daha fazla soru