Soru

Zorluk: ZorOverall Text Structure Analysis

For decades, historical linguists hypothesized that the spread of the Indo-European language family was driven primarily by the migration of pastoralists from the Pontic-Caspian steppe, a view supported by archaeological evidence of horse domestication. However, an alternative model proposes that the language family expanded much earlier alongside the spread of agriculture from Anatolia. Recently, researchers have sought to resolve this debate by using phylogeographic tools to analyze genomic data from ancient human remains. Their findings suggest a hybrid model, wherein the language family originated in the Caucasus and split into two distinct branches that expanded via separate routes.

Which choice best describes the overall structure of the text?

  1. A
    It describes a widely accepted scientific theory, details a primary objection to that theory, and then argues that a third theory should replace it entirely.
  2. B
    It asserts that pastoralist migrations are the primary cause of language expansion, supports this claim with archaeological evidence, and refutes an opposing model based on agricultural development.
  3. It introduces two competing explanations for a historical development, notes a recent scientific effort to address the disagreement, and summarizes a finding that offers a new synthesis of the two views.Cevap
  4. D
    It reviews a classic linguistic debate, outlines the specific genetic techniques used to analyze ancient human remains, and highlights the limitations of these computational methods.

Cevap

The correct answer is the option stating that the text introduces two competing explanations, notes a recent scientific effort to address the disagreement, and summarizes a finding that offers a new synthesis of the two views.
The correct answer accurately outlines the text's overall organization. The passage first presents two competing hypotheses regarding the spread of the Indo-European language family. It then introduces a recent study that utilized new analytical tools to resolve the conflict. Finally, it presents the study's conclusion, which integrates elements of both original hypotheses into a new hybrid model.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the initial debate introduced in the passage.
The text presents two differing theories on the spread of Indo-European languages: pastoralist migration and agricultural expansion.
This establishes the starting point of the overall text structure.
2
Analyze how the text introduces a transition.
The text states that researchers recently used new methods (phylogeographic analysis of ancient remains) to address the conflict.
This identifies the structural shift from presenting a debate to describing a method of inquiry.
3
Determine how the text concludes.
The final sentence reveals that the findings support a hybrid model combining elements of both theories.
This completes the structural overview by showing how the initial debate is resolved with a synthesis.

Anahtar Kavram

Overall Text Structure Analysis
Bu soruyu puanla