Soru

Zorluk: Çok zorSystematic and Market Risks

A retail investor holds a portfolio distributed across 100 different domestic stock mutual funds, representing thousands of public companies across all equity sectors and market capitalizations. During a prolonged macroeconomic tightening cycle characterized by elevated interest rates and falling stock indices, the market value of the entire portfolio declines significantly. The investor is surprised by the losses, believing that spreading capital across so many equity funds would provide complete loss protection. Which of the following statements best explains why this diversification strategy failed to protect the investor's portfolio?

  1. A
    Spreading capital across additional equity mutual funds completely eliminates market risk once a portfolio exceeds 50 distinct fund holdings.
  2. Asset diversification mitigates unsystematic (business-specific) risk, but cannot eliminate systematic (market) risk driven by broad macroeconomic factors.Cevap
  3. C
    The portfolio losses were primarily caused by issuer credit and default risk, which inherently increases across all equity holdings during rate hikes.
  4. D
    Rising interest rates cause yield curves to invert, automatically requiring open-end mutual fund managers to liquidate stock positions to satisfy debt covenants.

Cevap

Asset diversification mitigates unsystematic (business-specific) risk, but cannot eliminate systematic (market) risk driven by broad macroeconomic factors.
Diversification across many individual stocks or mutual funds successfully eliminates unsystematic (nonsystematic or business) risk. However, systematic risks—such as market risk, interest rate risk, and inflation risk—impact the entire market simultaneously due to broad economic forces. Therefore, expanding diversification across equity funds cannot protect against systematic market downturns.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the nature of the risks affecting the portfolio.
The investor holds a broad spectrum of equity funds, which eliminates unsystematic (specific/business) risk.
Unsystematic risk pertains to individual companies or specific sectors and is reduced through asset diversification.
2
Identify the cause of the portfolio decline during a general market downturn.
The decline is caused by systematic (market) risk factors, such as macroeconomic tightening and rising interest rates.
Systematic risks impact the aggregate economy and financial markets as a whole.
3
Evaluate the limitations of diversification regarding systematic risk.
Systematic risk cannot be eliminated by adding more equity positions or mutual funds.
Because all equities carry exposure to overall market fluctuations, hedging strategies (such as index options) rather than diversification are required to manage systematic risk.

Anahtar Kavram

Systematic risk (market risk) affects the broad economy and financial markets, making it impossible to eliminate through asset diversification.
Bu soruyu puanla