Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaEpidemiologic Study Designs

Researchers at a medical center are investigating a potential association between the use of a newly introduced class of weight-loss medications and the development of acute pancreatitis. To conduct the study, they review electronic health records to identify 150 patients who were admitted to the hospital with a confirmed diagnosis of acute pancreatitis over the past three years. They also randomly select 600 patients from the same hospital system who have never been diagnosed with acute pancreatitis, ensuring they are matched by age, sex, and body mass index. The research team then analyzes the past pharmacy dispensing records for all 750 individuals to determine how many had been prescribed the new weight-loss medication prior to the index date. Which of the following is the most appropriate statistical measure to report the strength of the association in this study?

  1. Odds ratioCevap
  2. B
    Relative risk
  3. C
    Prevalence ratio
  4. D
    Hazard ratio
  5. E
    Number needed to harm

Cevap

Odds ratio
The correct answer is the odds ratio. This vignette describes a case-control study. The investigators first identified patients with the outcome of interest (acute pancreatitis) and a matched control group without the outcome. They then looked retrospectively into their medical histories to ascertain their exposure status (use of weight-loss medications). Because case-control studies select participants based on disease status, they do not establish a true population at risk and therefore cannot measure the actual incidence of the disease. Consequently, measures that rely on incidence, such as relative risk or absolute risk, cannot be directly calculated. The odds ratio is the standard and appropriate measure of association used in case-control studies to estimate the relative risk.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the participant selection strategy.
Subjects were selected based on the presence (150 cases) or absence (600 controls) of acute pancreatitis.
Determining how the study groups were initially formed is the first step in identifying the study design.
2
Identify the temporal direction of the inquiry.
Researchers looked retrospectively at pharmacy records to determine past exposure to weight-loss medications.
The directionality of data collection (forward, backward, or simultaneous) distinguishes between different observational designs.
3
Synthesize the findings to name the study design.
Selecting by outcome and looking backward for exposure defines a case-control study.
Applying the definitions of epidemiologic study designs to the identified parameters.
4
Determine the appropriate statistical measure for this specific design.
Because case-control studies do not measure disease incidence, relative risk cannot be calculated; the odds ratio must be used.
Each study design is paired with specific valid statistical measures of association.

Anahtar Kavram

Case-control studies group subjects by their disease outcome status and look retrospectively to determine past exposure. Because they do not follow an at-risk population over time, disease incidence cannot be calculated, making the odds ratio the appropriate measure of association.
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Epidemiologic Study Designs

Bu konudan daha fazla soru