Question

Difficulty: EasyIdentifying Points of Agreement

Three scientists discuss the primary cause of a global cooling event that occurred millions of years ago.

Scientist 1
The cooling was caused by volcanic eruptions. Volcanic dust and sulfur dioxide gas (SO2SO_2) were injected into the stratosphere. These aerosols reflected incoming solar radiation back into space, reducing global surface temperatures. The cooling caused a rapid growth in polar ice sheets, which increased the Earth's albedo (reflectivity) and led to further cooling.

Scientist 2
The cooling was caused by the rapid expansion of early forests. The growth of these plants absorbed large amounts of carbon dioxide (CO2CO_2) from the atmosphere through photosynthesis. The reduction of this greenhouse gas decreased the atmosphere's ability to retain heat, leading to global cooling. Ocean temperatures dropped, which increased the amount of CO2CO_2 that dissolved in the oceans, further lowering atmospheric levels.

Scientist 3
The cooling was caused by a large asteroid impact. The impact blasted massive quantities of pulverized rock and dust into the upper atmosphere, blocking sunlight for several years. This dust layer reflected solar radiation, preventing it from warming the surface. The lack of sunlight caused widespread plant die-offs and triggered a long-term cooling cycle as snow cover expanded.

Match each of the following statements with the specific scientists who would agree with that statement.

  • The global cooling was triggered by a terrestrial volcanic event.Scientist 1 only
  • Atmospheric particles reflected incoming solar radiation to cause cooling.Scientists 1 and 3 only
  • The Earth's global temperatures decreased during this period.Scientists 1, 2, and 3

Answer

The statement regarding volcanic eruptions matches 'Scientist 1 only'; the statement about particles reflecting solar radiation matches 'Scientists 1 and 3 only'; and the statement about global temperatures decreasing matches 'Scientists 1, 2, and 3'.
Matching the statements correctly involves identifying which scientists support each claim. The belief that volcanic eruptions caused the cooling is unique to Scientist 1. The mechanism of cooling by dust/particle reflection of solar radiation is shared by Scientists 1 and 3. The occurrence of global cooling itself is agreed upon by all three scientists.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the claims of each scientist regarding the volcanic trigger.
Only Scientist 1 mentions volcanic eruptions causing the cooling event.
Scientist 2 mentions forest growth and Scientist 3 mentions an asteroid impact.
2
Identify which scientists discuss atmospheric particles reflecting sunlight.
Scientists 1 and 3 describe atmospheric particles (volcanic dust/sulfur aerosols and rock dust, respectively) reflecting solar radiation.
Scientist 2 describes cooling via carbon dioxide reduction rather than solar reflection by particles.
3
Determine if there is a common event that all three scientists agree occurred.
All three scientists agree that a period of global cooling took place.
Each scientist proposes a different hypothesis to explain the same observed cooling event.

Key Concept

Identifying points of agreement and disagreement among multiple scientific viewpoints.
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question