Question

Difficulty: MediumRelationships Between Sections and Paragraphs

The following passage is adapted from an article about the history of paleontology.

Paragraph 1
For nearly a century after the first dinosaur fossils were classified in the nineteenth century, scientists viewed these creatures through a strictly reptilian lens. Dinosaurs were reconstructed as slow, lumbering ectotherms—cold-blooded animals reliant on external heat sources to regulate their body temperature. This consensus was largely based on structural similarities between dinosaur skeletons and those of modern lizards. Because modern lizards have low metabolic rates and exhibit sluggish behavior in cold conditions, early paleontologists assumed that dinosaurs must have operated under similar physiological constraints.

Paragraph 2
This paradigm shifted dramatically in the late 1960s with the discovery of Deinonychus, a small, bird-like predator. Paleontologist John Ostrom pointed out that Deinonychus possessed a highly specialized skeleton designed for speed, agility, and active hunting. Ostrom argued that such high-energy behavior would be impossible for an ectothermic animal, suggesting instead that dinosaurs possessed a warm-blooded, endothermic metabolism. This discovery sparked the "Dinosaur Renaissance," a period of intense scientific debate that fundamentally reevaluated dinosaur biology.

Based on the passage, which of the following best describes how Paragraph 2 functions in relation to Paragraph 1?

  1. It introduces a specific discovery that challenged the long-held scientific assumption described in Paragraph 1.Answer
  2. B
    It provides detailed anatomical evidence that supports the traditional classification system introduced in Paragraph 1.
  3. C
    It outlines a historical timeline of fossil discoveries that occurred prior to the events described in Paragraph 1.
  4. D
    It focuses on the behavioral traits of modern lizards to explain the physiological constraints mentioned in Paragraph 1.

Answer

Paragraph 2 functions to introduce a discovery that challenged the traditional scientific consensus presented in Paragraph 1.
Paragraph 1 outlines the historical view that dinosaurs were sluggish ectotherms, while Paragraph 2 introduces John Ostrom's late 1960s study of Deinonychus, a discovery that challenged that consensus and initiated a scientific reevaluation of dinosaur physiology.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary topic and function of Paragraph 1.
Paragraph 1 explains the nineteenth-century consensus that dinosaurs were slow and cold-blooded, drawing comparisons to modern lizards.
Establishing the initial premise of the text is required before evaluating how subsequent paragraphs interact with it.
2
Identify the primary topic and function of Paragraph 2.
Paragraph 2 introduces the late 1960s discovery of Deinonychus and Ostrom's argument that its skeleton points to an active, warm-blooded lifestyle, which triggered a major scientific debate.
Analyzing the second paragraph allows us to see how it shifts or supports the ideas of the first.
3
Determine the logical connection between the two paragraphs.
Paragraph 2 details a discovery that actively contested the long-held assumptions laid out in Paragraph 1.
Synthesizing the functions of both sections identifies the correct relationship between them.

Key Concept

Identifying how one paragraph functions to challenge, support, or develop the ideas in another paragraph.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question