Question

Difficulty: HardComprehending Explicit Comparisons and Contrasts

Geochronologists rely on distinct isotopic systems to date ancient materials, choosing methods based on the composition and age of the sample. Radiocarbon dating determines the age of organic remains by measuring the ratio of unstable carbon-14 to stable carbon-12. This carbon is absorbed by living organisms from the atmosphere, and the measurement directly tracks the progressive loss of the radioactive isotope over time. Because of carbon-14’s relatively brief half-life of 5,730 years, this technique is precise only for materials under 50,000 years old, and it is entirely restricted to organic substances. In contrast, potassium-argon (K-Ar) dating measures the accumulation of gaseous argon-40, which is the decay product of radioactive potassium-40 found in volcanic minerals. Instead of measuring the depletion of a biological isotope, K-Ar dating measures the ratio of the parent isotope to the trapped daughter gas within solidified rock, a process initiated only when volcanic rock cools. With a half-life of 1.25 billion years, K-Ar dating is suited only for inorganic samples older than 100,000 years.

According to the passage, which of the following statements explicitly describes a difference between the mechanisms of radiocarbon dating and potassium-argon (K-Ar) dating?

  1. Radiocarbon dating tracks the depletion of an isotope absorbed by an organism during its lifetime, while potassium-argon dating measures the accumulation of a decay product trapped in rock after cooling.Answer
  2. B
    Radiocarbon dating measures the accumulation of stable carbon-14 isotopes over time, while potassium-argon dating measures the depletion of radioactive gaseous argon-40.
  3. C
    Radiocarbon dating analyzes the ratio of parent and daughter elements in inorganic samples under 50,000 years old, while potassium-argon dating measures the atmospheric exchange of gaseous elements.
  4. D
    Radiocarbon dating measures the rate at which living organisms absorb carbon from the atmosphere, while potassium-argon dating measures the rate of volcanic eruption cooling.

Answer

Radiocarbon dating tracks the depletion of an isotope absorbed by an organism during its lifetime, while potassium-argon dating measures the accumulation of a decay product trapped in rock after cooling.
The correct answer accurately reflects the explicit comparison in the passage. The text states that radiocarbon dating measures the ratio of carbon-14, which tracks the 'progressive loss' (depletion) of the isotope absorbed by organisms from the atmosphere. In contrast, potassium-argon (K-Ar) dating measures the 'accumulation of gaseous argon-40' (decay product) trapped within rock after it cools.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate where the passage describes the mechanism of radiocarbon dating.
The passage states that radiocarbon dating measures the ratio of unstable carbon-14 to stable carbon-12 to track the progressive loss (depletion) of the carbon-14 absorbed by organisms from the atmosphere during life.
Establishing the literal mechanism of the first method is necessary to compare it to the second.
2
Locate where the passage describes the mechanism of potassium-argon (K-Ar) dating.
The passage states that K-Ar dating measures the accumulation of gaseous argon-40 (the decay product) trapped inside volcanic rock after it cools.
Establishing the literal mechanism of the second method allows for a direct comparison of the two.
3
Compare the two mechanisms to find the statement that accurately contrasts them based on the text.
The correct comparison identifies that radiocarbon dating tracks the depletion of an isotope absorbed by an organism, whereas K-Ar dating tracks the accumulation of a decay product trapped in cooled rock.
This matches the explicit contrast stated in the text without distorting any details or definitions.

Key Concept

Comprehending Explicit Comparisons and Contrasts
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question