Question

Difficulty: MediumSentence Addition and Deletion Decisions

A writer is editing a draft of an essay about photographic history.

[1] In 1842, astronomer and chemist Sir John Herschel invented the cyanotype, a photographic printing process that produces a Prussian blue monochrome image. [2] Herschel was primarily looking for a reliable way to copy his extensive mathematical and astronomical notes without having to rewrite them by hand. [3] The process involves coating paper with a solution of ammonium iron(III) citrate and potassium ferricyanide, which is then dried in the dark. [4] When exposed to ultraviolet light, the chemicals react to form an insoluble blue dye, while the unexposed areas remain white after being washed with water. [5] Herschel's invention eventually became highly popular among architects and engineers in the twentieth century for reproducing technical drawings, which is how the term 'blueprint' originated.

The writer is considering deleting Sentence 2 from the passage. Should the writer make this deletion?

  1. A
    Yes, because the sentence introduces details about Herschel's personal notes that are irrelevant to the chemical explanation of the cyanotype process.
  2. B
    Yes, because the sentence shifts the focus of the paragraph from the history of cyanotypes to Herschel's other achievements in astronomy.
  3. No, because the sentence explains the original purpose that motivated Herschel to develop the cyanotype process.Answer
  4. D
    No, because the sentence provides essential historical evidence showing that copying notes by hand was a common practice in the nineteenth century.

Answer

The sentence should not be deleted because it explains the original purpose that motivated Herschel to develop the cyanotype process.
The sentence should be kept because it explains the original purpose that motivated Herschel to develop the cyanotype process. Deleting this sentence would leave a gap in the narrative, as the reader would not understand why Herschel sought to invent this photographic process in the first place.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Sentence 2 in the context of the paragraph to determine its role.
Sentence 2 explains that Herschel wanted to find a reliable way to copy his mathematical and astronomical notes without rewriting them.
This identifies the specific information that would be lost if the sentence were deleted.
2
Evaluate the relevance of this information to the overall passage.
The passage discusses the invention, mechanism, and legacy of the cyanotype. Explaining why Herschel developed the process directly supports the main idea of how the cyanotype came to be.
This determines whether the sentence should be kept (No) or deleted (Yes).
3
Compare the correct stance (No) with the provided reasons in the choices.
The option explaining that the sentence provides the motivating purpose behind the invention matches the logical function of the text.
This yields the final correct answer.

Key Concept

Evaluating the relevance of supporting details and structural cohesion when deciding whether to add or delete sentences.
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question