Question

Difficulty: MediumSelecting Concluding Sentences and Transitions

In 1857, French inventor Édouard-Léon Scott de Martinville patented the phonautograph, the earliest known device for recording sound. Unlike Thomas Edison's phonograph, which could both record and play back audio, Scott's invention was designed only to write sound waves onto soot-coated paper. Scott believed that these visual transcriptions, which he called "phonautograms," could eventually be read by eye. Consequently, because he never intended for his recordings to be heard, they remained silent, unplayed artifacts for over a century.

In 2008, scientists at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory utilized digital scanning technology to examine Scott's surviving papers. By mapping the soot patterns and translating them into digital audio files, they successfully recovered the voice of a woman singing the French folk song "Au Clair de la Lune." [1]

The writer wants to add a sentence at [1] to conclude the passage by emphasizing the historic significance of Scott's invention. Which choice most effectively accomplishes this goal?

  1. A
    Thomas Edison, who would later invent the phonograph in 1877, also developed a system for motion pictures that revolutionized the entertainment industry.
  2. Although Scott died believing his work was a failure, the successful recovery of these sounds proved that his device had indeed captured the first recorded voice in human history.Answer
  3. C
    This modern breakthrough finally brought Scott's silent recordings to life, it transformed our understanding of early audio technology.
  4. D
    The digital technology, that the scientists used to play the recordings, proved that Scott's device was a historic success.

Answer

The sentence concluding that although Scott died believing his work was a failure, the successful recovery of these sounds proved that his device had indeed captured the first recorded voice in human history.
The correct choice effectively concludes the passage by linking the recovery of Scott's phonautograms to the significance of his invention, highlighting that it successfully captured the first recorded voice in human history. It introduces no grammatical errors and directly satisfies the rhetorical goal.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the writing goal specified in the prompt.
The goal is to conclude the passage by emphasizing the historic significance of Scott's invention.
Identifying the precise rhetorical goal helps eliminate options that focus on irrelevant details.
2
Evaluate the options for relevance and completeness of content.
The option summarizing Scott's legacy as the first recorded voice successfully meets this goal, whereas the option about Edison's movie technology introduces unrelated details.
A strong conclusion must wrap up the main theme without introducing new, unsupported details.
3
Examine the remaining options for grammatical correctness.
The option with the comma splice and the option with commas around the restrictive clause are grammatically incorrect.
ACT English questions require that the correct option must also be free of grammatical errors.

Key Concept

Selecting Concluding Sentences and Transitions
Rate this question