Question

Difficulty: MediumComprehending Explicit Comparisons and Contrasts

Passage:

For centuries, early mariners relied on the astrolabe to navigate the open seas. The astrolabe allowed sailors to determine latitude by measuring the angle of a celestial body above the horizon. However, its accuracy was severely compromised by the motion of a pitching ship, as the device relied on gravity to align its vertical scale. In contrast, the marine sextant, introduced in the eighteenth century, resolved this instability. By utilizing a system of mirrors to bring the image of a star into alignment with the horizon, the sextant enabled navigators to measure angles directly between two points. Consequently, while the astrolabe required a stable platform to maintain its vertical orientation, the sextant functioned independently of gravity, allowing precise readings even on turbulent waters.

Based on the passage, how did the operational requirements of the astrolabe differ from those of the marine sextant?

  1. The astrolabe required a stable platform to align its gravity-dependent scale, whereas the sextant functioned independently of gravity.Answer
  2. B
    The astrolabe utilized a system of mirrors to align stars with the horizon, whereas the sextant relied on a physical pendulum.
  3. C
    The astrolabe was introduced in the eighteenth century for use on turbulent waters, whereas the sextant was developed centuries earlier.
  4. D
    The astrolabe was used to determine the ship's latitude, whereas the sextant was used exclusively to measure local time.

Answer

The astrolabe required a stable platform to align its gravity-dependent scale, whereas the sextant functioned independently of gravity.
The correct answer accurately reflects the explicit contrast stated in the final sentence of the passage: the astrolabe required a stable platform because it relied on gravity, whereas the sextant functioned independently of gravity and could handle turbulent waters.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the description of the astrolabe's operation and operational challenges in the passage.
The passage states that the astrolabe's accuracy was 'severely compromised by the motion of a pitching ship, as the device relied on gravity to align its vertical scale.'
This establishes the physical constraint and requirements of the astrolabe.
2
Locate the description of the marine sextant's mechanism and how it resolved the astrolabe's instability.
The passage notes that the sextant used a 'system of mirrors' and 'functioned independently of gravity, allowing precise readings even on turbulent waters.'
This identifies the contrasting operational capabilities of the marine sextant.
3
Compare the two findings to identify the explicit contrast.
The astrolabe required stability because of its reliance on gravity, while the sextant did not require stability as it was gravity-independent.
This direct comparison allows for the selection of the correct option.

Key Concept

Comprehending Explicit Comparisons and Contrasts
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question