Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Narrator Point of View

The preservation of the old dock was not, as the town council claimed, a matter of historical pride. To me, it was a ledger of summers spent watching the tide drag silt across the salt marsh, a structure whose slowly rotting pine beams held the weight of my childhood. When the demolition crews arrived in late autumn, they brought with them the cold, efficient language of progress—phrases like 'structural liability' and 'recreational zoning.' They spoke of the dock as if it were a math problem to be solved, completely blind to the fact that its very decay was part of the river’s rhythm. I stood at the edge of the gravel road, notebook in hand, ostensibly to document the event for the local historical society, but in truth, I was there to keep a silent vigil. As the first excavator claw tore into the pier, the splintering wood sounded like a sharp intake of breath. The workers did not pause; they were merely agents of a distant municipal will, eager to finish before the first snowfall. But for those of us who had carved our initials into the handrails, the loss was not measured in timber or concrete, but in the sudden, quiet vacancy of the shoreline.

Which of the following best describes the narrator's point of view regarding the demolition of the old dock?

  1. A first-person narrator who has a close personal connection to the dock and perceives its destruction as a significant emotional loss.Answer
  2. B
    The author of the passage, who is offering an objective historical analysis of why the town council decided to demolish the pier.
  3. C
    A first-person observer who is neutral about the demolition and values the dock primarily as a subject for academic research.
  4. D
    A member of the demolition crew who sympathizes with the town council's desire to modernize the waterfront.

Answer

A first-person narrator who has a close personal connection to the dock and perceives its destruction as a significant emotional loss.
The correct answer accurately identifies the narrator's point of view as first-person, supported by the use of personal pronouns, and correctly describes their attitude as one of emotional attachment and personal loss in response to the dock's destruction.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the narrative pronouns to determine the narrative voice.
The narrator uses first-person pronouns such as 'me', 'my', and 'I' ('To me, it was a ledger...', 'my childhood', 'I stood'), identifying this as a first-person narrative.
Establishing the narrative voice is the first step in identifying the point of view.
2
Examine the narrator's relationship to the subject matter and tone.
The narrator speaks of 'summers spent' and the 'weight of my childhood,' showing a personal connection. The demolition is described with words like 'loss,' 'silent vigil,' and 'vacancy,' indicating a subjective, mournful, and emotional perspective rather than a neutral or municipal one.
This helps determine the narrator's specific attitude and relationship to the story elements.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that accurately describes this first-person, emotionally connected perspective.
The choice describing a first-person narrator with a close personal connection who feels a significant emotional loss matches the findings.
This confirms the correct option while eliminating choices that mischaracterize the tone or confuse the narrator with the author or other characters.

Key Concept

Identifying Narrator Point of View
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question