Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Points of Agreement

### The Great Unconformity

The Great Unconformity is a global geological phenomenon where Cambrian-aged sedimentary rocks rest directly on top of much older igneous or metamorphic basement rocks, representing a gap in the rock record of up to 1 billion1\text{ billion} years. Three geologists propose different hypotheses for the cause of this gap.

Geologist 1
The unconformity was caused by massive glacial erosion during the Neoproterozoic "Snowball Earth" glaciations. Widespread, thick ice sheets covered the continents and scraped away kilometers of the Earth's crust, dumping the sediment into the oceans. This global glacial scour removed pre-Cambrian rock layers, creating the distinct erosional surface before Cambrian sediments were deposited.

Geologist 2
The unconformity was driven by tectonic processes related to the assembly and breakup of the supercontinent Rodinia. The collision of tectonic plates caused massive crustal uplift, exposing vast continental areas. Wind and rain then eroded the uplifted rock over millions of years. This subaerial erosion stripped away the older rock layers prior to Cambrian marine transgressions.

Geologist 3
The unconformity was caused by a severe, globally coordinated drop in sea level. As oceans receded, continental shelves were exposed to the atmosphere. Rain, rivers, and wind eroded the exposed rocks, removing centuries of geological history. Widespread erosion occurred until sea levels rose again during the Cambrian period, depositing new sediment over the eroded surface.

Based on the passage, all three geologists would agree with which of the following statements regarding the creation of the Great Unconformity?

  1. A
    Tectonic plate collisions and continental uplift directly caused the unconformity.
  2. Erosion removed older rock layers before Cambrian sediment was deposited.Answer
  3. C
    Widespread glacial activity was the primary agent responsible for stripping the crust.
  4. D
    A global drop in sea level was the main cause of continental rock exposure.

Answer

Erosion removed older rock layers before Cambrian sediment was deposited.
The correct answer states that erosion removed older rock layers before Cambrian sediment was deposited. All three geologists agree that erosion was the primary physical process responsible for removing pre-existing rock layers to create the unconformity surface, though they disagree on the specific triggers (glaciation, supercontinent dynamics, or sea-level drop) and agents (glaciers vs. wind/rain/rivers).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary mechanism proposed by Geologist 1.
Geologist 1 attributes the unconformity to glacial erosion that scraped away kilometers of the Earth's crust.
To determine how Geologist 1 explains the loss of rock layers.
2
Identify the primary mechanism proposed by Geologist 2.
Geologist 2 attributes the unconformity to subaerial erosion (by wind and rain) of uplifted continental rocks.
To determine how Geologist 2 explains the loss of rock layers.
3
Identify the primary mechanism proposed by Geologist 3.
Geologist 3 attributes the unconformity to erosion by rain, rivers, and wind of continental shelves exposed by falling sea levels.
To determine how Geologist 3 explains the loss of rock layers.
4
Compare the proposed mechanisms to find a shared concept.
All three geologists attribute the gap in the rock record to erosion removing the older rock layers prior to Cambrian sedimentation, despite proposing different geological triggers (glaciation, supercontinent dynamics, or sea-level drops) and agents (glaciers vs. meteoric weathering).
To identify the point of agreement among all three geologists.

Key Concept

Identifying points of agreement among conflicting scientific viewpoints
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Identifying Points of Agreement

More questions from this topic